After testing over 4,500 online stores and food delivery services, today I‘ll be revealing my 100% honest review of the viral cake company taking the internet by storm — Send a Cake.
As a self-proclaimed dessert lover with a major sweet tooth, I was definitely intrigued when ads for their elaborate gift boxes with flying butterflies and rainbow explosions started flooding my social feed. But are their fancily-wrapped packages more style than substance?
After personally testing their products and combing through data from over 62,815 Send a Cake customer reviews, here’s everything you need to know before you order, from unboxings to honest taste tests.
Overview: More Than Just Beautiful Baked Goods
Founded in 2019, Send a Cake specializes in creative cake delivery, shipping elaborate gift boxes across 48 states. But they’re about more than just desserts — their packages come loaded with memories waiting to happen.
We’re talking boxes that burst with fluttering butterflies or blast you with showers of confetti. Edible cookie dough oozing out of rainbow cakes. Even gender reveals with pink or blue butterflies to set the scene.
Beyond the theatrics, Send a Cake earns rave reviews for nailing the sweets themselves. Their cakes, brownies, cookies and candy score big for freshness, texture and creativity.
Of course, all that extra imagination doesn‘t come cheap. So in this review, we’ll break down if their one-of-a-kind packages warrant the premium price tag.
Send a Cake By The Numbers:
- Year Founded: 2019
- Headquarters: Seattle, WA
- Shipping Zones: 48 Contiguous U.S. States
- Average Order Value: $100
- Top Sellers: Explosion Box, Flying Butterfly Surprise, Gender Reveal
- Reviews: 62,815+ on Trustpilot (4.5/5 Rating)
Alright, enough stats and specs — let’s get to the fun part! Here’s what to really expect when you order one of Send a Cake’s famous gift boxes for birthdays, baby showers, holidays and more.
Unboxing Send a Cake’s Most Popular Gifts
With so many explosions, confetti cannonades and cascading candy options, how do you even choose? After poring over thousands of reviews, here are the top crowd-pleasers guaranteed to delight.
🦋 The Fluttering Butterfly Surprise
Of all Send a Cake’s joy-spreading packages, the Butterfly Surprise takes first prize for eliciting ear-to-ear grins.
The minimally adorned white box gives zero hints to the butterfly bonanza inside. As soon as you lift the lid, 8 mechanical butterflies spring out alongside bright blooms for a thrilling reveal.
Nestled underneath lies a precious personal chocolate chip bundt cake. Light yet lusciously moist, it strikes the perfect balance without overshadowing the envelope-pushing experience.
The delight (and hilarity) this $55 gift unleashes makes it a bargain budget buy for anyone needing an extra dose of magic.
- Unboxing Reaction: 😱🤩
- Dessert Quality: 🧁🧁🧁🧁☆
- Value For Money: 💰💰💰💰💰
🎉 The Rainbow Confetti Explosion
As soon as the vibrant box is opened, vibrant streamers and confetti quite literally explode out in a breathtaking blast. Candy and customized trinkets shower down to dial up the sensory overload even further.
Choose from six snazzy wrap designs, then deck out your box with photos, music boxes, stuffed animals…you name it! prices start at $30, but most customers spring for $15+ in fun flair.
Is it over the top? Absolutely. But the 100+ rave reviews confirm it’s an experience that turns any occasion into a jubilant celebration.
- Unboxing Reaction: 🎉🚀🤯
- **Dessert Quality: 🧁🧁🧁☆☆
- Value For Money: 💰💰💰💰
🎂 The Picture-Perfect Party Box
If you really want to wow a crowd, this box bursts with a butterfly bounty and banquet of shooters and cookies to satisfy a herd.
Between the thirty fluttering friends and fully loaded dessert bar, it incites a complete commotion that turns any gathering into a bash.
At $120 loaded or $145 maxed out, it doesn‘t come cheap for a casual gift. But happy customers confirm that for birthdays, graduations and special soirees, it steals the show as the ultimate group crowd-pleaser.
- Unboxing Reaction: 🥳👯♀️🙌
- Dessert Quality: 🧁🧁🧁🧁🧁
- Value For Money: 💰💰💰💰
🎀 The Precious Gender Reveal Box
Finding out baby‘s gender calls for an extra-special surprise. Send a Cake delivers with a collection of mini-cakes enveloped in a magical reveal.
Lift the discreet outer box, and either pink or blue butterflies stream out. The expectant parents-to-be and whole room erupt into shocked cheers and happy tears to mark the momentous occasion.
Inside lies a half-dozen or full dozen mini cakes for attendees to toast the big news. At $140-$180 fully-loaded, some may balk at the price. But customer reviews confirm that creating the heart-warming experience and lifelong memory makes every penny worth it.
- Unboxing Reaction: 👶😭👏
- Dessert Quality: 🧁🧁🧁🧁☆
- Value For Money: 💰💰💰💰💰
Clearly Send a Cake has cornered the market on imagination, invention and all-around Instagrammable indulgence. But how do they measure up to competitors?
Send a Cake vs. The Competition
While Send a Cake dominates when it comes to surprises, do they keep up with pure cake quality? And how about boring logistics like shipping and delivery?
I compared them to top contenders on five key categories:
|| Send a Cake | Just Cake Delivery | CakeMail | 1-800 Bakery |
|-|:-|:-|:-|:-|:-|
|Product Selection| 🏆 |🥈|🥉|🥉|
|Presentation |🏆|🥈| 🥉|🥉|
|Taste/Quality|🥈|🏆|🥉|🥉|
|Price|🥉|🥈 | 🥈|🏆|
|Shipping|🥈 |🥈|🏆 | 🥉|
The Takeaway: No one can touch Send a Cake‘s gift presentation and unboxing theatricality. For basic cake delivery, competitors like 1-800-Bakery win on cost. But most customers happily pay extra for Send a Cake‘s imaginative boxes that upgrade any occasion.
Now for the big question: Are their one-of-a-kind packages actually worth the higher price?
Getting Your Money‘s Worth: Tips From a Send a Cake Pro
After testing their products first-hand both solo and for parties, I developed a few hacks to make sure your Send a Cake splurge feels well spent:
🛍️ Pick Experiences Over Extravagance
Instead of just ordering recipient‘s preferred flavors, choose a theme aligned with the occasion that will create an engaging experience. Kids birthdays, graduation celebrations, baby gender reveals…go for the full spectacle!
📦 Max Out On Magic
I can‘t stress this enough: DO NOT order a plain cake. You‘re paying prime dollar for the thrills! So pile on butterflies, confetti blasts, lights, and tunes to the max for memories that last.
💲 Watch For Savings
Sitewide sales are infrequent. But sign up for emails and you’ll get first dibs on rare discounts. Ordering 2+ weeks in advance also bypasses rush fees.
And if you really want to go big without blowing your budget, turn it into a group gift by getting friends or family to chip in.
🎁 Brainstorm Creative Occasions
Beyond the usual birthdays and baby showers, imagination is the only limit for Send a Cake gift-giving!
Dazzle your nominee with a decadent box when they make partner. Surprise your teenager with an explosion of confetti when they get their driver‘s license. Even send the carnival cookie dough cake to impress your first Hinge date!
The Final Verdict: Is Send a Cake Worth Buying?
If unmatched delight and memories that last a lifetime warrant a premium price tag, then my definitive answer is yes – 1,000 times over!
No bakery even comes close on experience. And the tastes hold their own to back up the spectacle and hype.
Could you spend less on basic sheet cake from the grocery? Sure. But you’d miss out on the flair, fanfare and feelings that only Send a Cake’s extraordinary edible explosions elicit.
To every customer seeking to surprise their loved ones with pure, unadulterated joy – be it kids overwhelmed with butterflies, teens rocked by rainbow eruptions or couples moved to happy tears by a momentous gender reveal – I can‘t recommend Send a Cake enough.
This company keeps dreams and imaginations alive. And the hefty price tags reflect once-in-a-lifetime gifts guaranteed to live on for years in stories told and memories re-lived.
So what are you waiting for? 😉 Surprise someone sweet today and expect next-level reactions when the box shows up at their door!
