As a mom of three young kids, I‘ve spent my fair share of time and money in baby stores searching for that perfect coming home outfit or snuggly jammies on cold nights. When I first discovered Spearmint Love back in 2015, I was intrigued by their promise to deliver the most unique and fashion-forward baby styles from over 140 brands. Now, after years of shopping from their site for my own little ones, it‘s time I share my insider perspective in this tell-all Spearmint Love review.
Overview and Backstory of Spearmint Love
Spearmint Love was founded in 2013 by mompreneur Shari Lott as an offshoot of her popular mommy blog, Spearmint Baby. As the story goes, Shari was searching all over for an American-made Swiss cross baby blanket as a gift and came up empty-handed. Her solution? Make them herself right here in the U.S. That first blanket quickly led to a full baby clothing and accessory collection now featuring over 5,000 products.
Since those early Etsy days, Spearmint Love has exploded into one of the internet‘s top destinations for modern and minimalist baby style. The site even collaborates with celebrities like Kristin Cavallari on limited-edition collections. For this Spearmint Love review, I took a deep-dive into the highs and lows of shopping this popular baby brand.
The Good
- Massive selection of apparel, shoes, accessories covering newborn through 36 months
- Exclusive products not sold elsewhere
- Convenient shopping categories like gender, size, brand, and collection
- Standard U.S. shipping is free
- Returns accepted within 7 days of delivery
The Not So Amazing
- Pricing is on the higher end, $20+ per piece
- Strong lean towards boutique minimalist aesthetic
- Numerous complaints of incorrect/damaged shipments
- Inconsistent sizing across brands and products
- Restocking fees apply for returns
Reviewing Some of Spearmint Love‘s Best Sellers
As the next part of my Spearmint Love review process, I‘m sharing mini product reviews for some of their top items that we‘ve personally tried and tested.
Organic Waffle Ruffle Zip Footie Snow – $42
This cozy organic footie met all my ideal baby jammies criteria with the foldover mitt cuff, full front zipper for easy diaper duty, plus a sweet ruffle running head to toe. I loved dressing my son snug as a bug to brave brisk fall walks. Sizing does come up small so consider going a size up.
Organic Waffle Knot Beanie – $17
Once winter hit, we lived in these knotted beanies made from breathable, chemical-free cotton. I appreciate how they stretch to fit growing heads from newborn through 12 months. Adorable styling yet perfectly functional to keep tiny ears nice and toasty.
Play Mat Taggies Monkey – $73
This portable play mat proved handy for creating a clean floor space for tummy time anywhere. The crinkly crackly ribbons provided endless amusement for little hands learning to grasp. My one complaint is the ribbon trim started pilling fairly quickly.
Classic Muslin Crib Sheet – $39
Transitioning my daughter from a baby to a "big girl" bed meant updating her linens. I chose this OKEO-TEX certified sheet for its cool, crisp feel and understated cloud pattern that works for either gender as a hand-me-down. After many washes it maintains its softness and has held up better than ones double this price.
What Do Other Spearmint Love Shoppers Think?
Curious how other moms and dads rate their Spearmint Love orders, I turned to reviews on BabyCenter, Facebook, TrustPilot and the Better Business Bureau. On BabyCenter moms raved about the wider availability of coveted brands compared to stores. One mom gushed "Their Estella NYC line is to die for."
Scrolling through Spearmint‘s Facebook though revealed multiple complaints about wrong or damaged shipments. A dad vented his frustration when a keepsake gown arrived with stains and holes, but he did eventually get a replacement sent.
I noticed over fifty 1-star TrustPilot ratings focused around owner Shari Lott‘s controversial past regarding adopted children. While certainly troubling actions if true, most admitted the clothes themselves were high quality hence my still recommending the brand.
The Better Business Bureau lists an A+ rating for Spearmint Love with contact details readily available. Reach their customer service at 1-877-577-0580 or [email protected] from Monday – Friday, 9 AM to 6 PM EST.
Key Takeaways From My Spearmint Love Review
- Massive selection of modern baby styles you won‘t find elsewhere
- Free shipping incentives and 10% off coupon for joining email list
- Prone to shipping/inventory mistakes resulting in delays
- Sizing varies greatly so thoroughly read measurements
- Expect boutique price tags from $25-$50 per piece
If you don‘t mind the extra effort verifying item details and managing returns when needed, Spearmint Love offers a baby fashion selection unlike any other. Just maybe avoid placing that special coming home outfit order at the last minute!
Have your own experience to share for this Spearmint Love review? Let other parents know in the comments!
