Sustainable fashion is on the rise. More and more brands are using eco-friendly materials and responsible production methods to reduce their environmental impact. Two brands leading this movement in footwear are Cariuma and Allbirds.
Both Cariuma and Allbirds have quickly become popular for their comfortable, stylish shoes made from sustainable materials like bamboo, wool and recycled plastics. But with similar missions, how do you choose between the two brands? This in-depth comparison outlines everything you need to know.
An Overview of Cariuma and Allbirds
Cariuma was founded in 2018 by David Python and Fernando Porto as an environmentally friendly alternative to mainstream shoe brands. Headquartered in Rio De Janeiro, Brazil, Cariuma partners with local factories to produce shoes predominantly using bamboo, rubber trees and recycled plastics. They are committed to ethical working conditions, donating 2% of revenue to social and environmental causes.
Allbirds launched in 2016 by Tim Brown and Joey Zwillinger with a focus on developing sustainable materials like merino wool and tree fibers. The certified B Corp brand quickly found success with their distinctive Wool Runners. Allbirds‘ production is carbon neutral and every material they use aims to reduce environmental impact over synthetic alternatives.
Comparing Popular Shoe Styles
Analyzing a few similar styles from both brands demonstrates their similarities and differences:
Sneakers:
Cariuma Catiba Pro ($89) – Canvas and suede skate shoes featuring memory foam insoles and durable rubber soles made from responsibly tapped rubber trees.
Allbirds Wool Runners ($110) – Iconic running shoes knit from moisture-wicking and temperature-regulating merino wool. SweetFoam soles derived from renewable sugarcane provide cushioning and comfort.
For everyday wear, the Allbirds Wool Runners win for comfort and breathability. The merino wool molds perfectly to feet. However, the Catiba Pro lasts longer, making them better value per wear for an active lifestyle.
Loafers:
Cariuma OCA Low ($98) – Understated low-top loafers crafted from grey suede and cotton canvas with leather lining and insole. The durable rubber sole adds grip.
Allbirds Tree Loungers ($100) – Slip-on loafers made of silky soft eucalyptus tree fiber, a renewable material requiring less water and chemicals to grow than cotton. The flexible sugar sole provides stability and cushioning.
For leisurely wear, the Allbirds Tree Loungers are simply unbeatable in comfort. The eucalyptus upper molds perfectly to feet like a second skin. However, the Cariuma loafers edge out in everyday versatility with their classy suede leather and durable rubber sole.
Sustainability Credentials
As sustainable brands, the materials and processes used matter. Allbirds reveals more specifics about their materials‘ sustainability online while Cariuma focuses more on social responsibility programs. Ultimately both utilize innovative materials with low environmental impact.
Brand Reputation
Customers praise both Cariuma and Allbirds for their ethical practices and consistent quality. However Allbirds earns slightly higher reviews for durable comfort even after years of wear. The most frequent complaint about Cariuma is shoes wearing out ahead of expectations.
Affordability and Value
Cariuma offers free shipping and returns on all orders to the USA. Their referral program also gives $30 off for customers and friends.
Allbirds provides free shipping and returns only on orders over $50. They rarely offer discounts or sales in order to maintain sustainable pricing.
Ultimately Cariuma has better value for money spent when you account for policies and promotions.
The Verdict
While Cariuma wins points for value, style variety and social initiatives, Allbirds remains ahead in customer experience. Their innovative materials set a new standard for sustainable comfort and durability. For easy, carefree wear over years, Allbirds still can‘t be beaten – especially their signature Wool Runners.
However Cariuma makes an excellent choice for someone wanting ethical kicks on a budget. Their canvas and suede styles particularly provide affordable options tailored to urban streetwear.
Overall both brands prove leading the future of eco-conscious footwear is about comfort meeting sustainability. Instead of seeing them as competition, the success of Allbirds and Cariuma symbolizes positive change coming for responsible brands.
