Hey there! Like you, I‘ve struggled with losing weight sustainably for years. I‘m Mark, an average guy working a busy job and raising a family.
I don‘t have chef-prepared meals or hours a day to dedicate to crazy workout regimes. I just need something straightforward that fits my lifestyle.
This year, I finally committed to trying the South Beach Diet after seeing some pretty unbelievable before and after photos online. I know, I know – everything on social media should be taken with a giant grain of salt.
But the stories seemed so inspiring. People claimed to fairly effortlessly lose 8, 10, even 15 pounds or more in just the 14 day "Phase 1" kickoff period.
Could a diet really deliver weight loss so rapidly? I was eager to find out.
This article gives you the real, nitty gritty results from a regular guy who lived the South Beach life for 90 days. Get ready for a day-by-day playback with no detail spared!
Overview of the South Beach Diet
South Beach at its core is lower-carb diet, but it‘s split into 3 phases:
Phase 1: Jumpstarts weight loss through 2 weeks of strictly low-glycemic carbs only. We‘re talking no fruit, grains, rice, potatoes, etc.
Phase 2: Slowly reintroduces some healthier carbs back while still promoting weight loss. Keep going until you hit your goal.
Phase 3: For maintenance once target weight is reached. Focus is whole foods-based "clean eating."
The diet was created by Dr. Arthur Agatston, a cardiologist, to improve patients‘ heart health. By stabilizing insulin and blood sugar levels first, it aims to reduce hunger levels and eliminate cravings.
This process should then make fat burning almost effortless according to South Beach creator Dr. Agatston. But does it actually play out so easily? Let‘s dig in…
Phase 1, Day 1: First Day Jitters
Welp, time to kiss fruits, grains and sweets goodbye for 2 weeks…I sheepishly took my last bite of banana and granola at breakfast.
My first Phase 1 meal plan called for 3 eggs, 2 strips of turkey bacon and 1/2 an avocado. It was…fine. Filling enough thanks to the healthy fats.
But snacking was tough without my usual apples, yogurt or nuts. I almost caved and ate dried fruit before realizing nope – fruit means sugar, so it‘s banned! Had some tuna and pickles instead.
Strangely, I didn‘t feel that satisfied despite technically eating plenty of food. I gotta say, going super low carb makes your body feel confused!
Phase 1, Day 4: Sleepy and Carb Crazy
Is it normal to feel kind of slow and carb starved at this point? Getting concerned. Dragging majorly despite eating plenty of protein and fats.
Woke up really irritable and immediately craving oatmeal. Attempted a breakfast sandwich with low-carb seed bread. It helped a bit.
But man, trying not to snack on ANY fruits, starchy veggies or grains left me feeling downright hangry by mid-afternoon! Had some celery sticks and peanut butter to cope.
Phase 1, Days 10-14: This Is TOUGH
The second week of Phase 1 started out more hopeful. I steadily got over the hump of carb cravings and lack of energy. Having prepared meat, eggs and approved veggie snacks on hand is crucial!
But days 10-14 tested my willpower to the extreme. I swear I was fantasizing about dinner rolls and fruit. And I mean truly obsessing over it!
I even broke down on my son‘s birthday and had a tiny bite of cake. What can I say, dads aren‘t perfect! But I hopped right back on the wagon.
These intense, vivid food cravings seem to be a really common challenge in Phase 1 based on support groups. So if you cave a little, go easy on yourself! It‘s those first 2-7 days that are vital to see results.
Phase 1 Results: Some Pounds Down But It‘s Been ROUGH!
I survived! Barely…
I lost right around 5-6 pounds in 2 weeks. Not the 10+ pounds promised on the official site, but I also cheated 2-3 times so honestly I can‘t complain.
However – and this is a big HOWEVER – I felt absolutely terrible physically and mentally that second week. Cravings through the roof, mind totally obsessed with foods I "couldn‘t" have.
I had to ask myself, is this sustainable long term? This level of deprivation left me feeling anxious, bummed out and not fully enjoying my life.
But I really did see quick results just by powering through the very low carb intake at first. So how to make those results last in a less miserable way? Enter Phase 2…
Phase 2 Goals: Keep Slimming Down in a More Flexible Way
After reflecting on my Phase 1 agony vs success slimming down, I decided to take Dr. Agatston‘s "phase" concept…and modify it to fit my needs.
My goal is to lose 1-2 pounds per week consistently without driving myself crazy. So I‘ll pick and choose aspects of Phase 2 strategically while ignoring advice that hurts more than helps!
Here‘s my personal "Phase 2 Remix" guidelines:
-
Slowly work appropriate fruits, beans and whole grains back in
-
Always ask: does this actually make me feel satisfied and happy? If no, skip it!
-
Pay attention to serving sizes with carbs – moderation matters
-
Learn to lose with occasional light life enjoyment! Aka don‘t panic if having a normal slice of birthday cake or dinner out. Just get back on track.
Let‘s see if this less extreme approach keeps me steadily progressing while regaining mental balance and life satisfaction…
My Phase 2 Results After 1 Month: It‘s Working!
It‘s been 30 days since I started my Phase 2 Remix diet and I. Am. SHOCKED!
I‘ve lost right around….(drumroll please)… 10 pounds this month!!!
By strategically incorporating berries, lentils, quinoa, sprouted bread and occasional corn tortillas back in, the results kept coming WITHOUT daily distress!
Don‘t get me wrong – it hasn‘t been easy breezy. Committing to consistent workout sessions, weigh-ins, smaller portions and very little junk foods took discipline.
BUT allowing elements of normal life back in (dinners out twice a week, the odd dessert, ketchup with my eggs lol) brought so much happiness.
And learning moderation prevented the same level of obsessiveness I experienced in Phase 1. I didn‘t have to feel deprived because hey, I can actually eat XYZ foods sometimes without going overboard!
6 Month Checkpoint: 25 Pounds Down and SO Much Healthier!
Wanted to check back in after 6 months of doing my own "everyman" version of the South Beach Diet. And I still have such great news to share!
In total, I‘ve lost 25 pounds following a template of:
-
Keeping grains, rice and starchy veggies to 1-2 modest servings daily
-
Enjoying 2-3 servings of lower sugar fruits
-
Building meals around lean proteins and smart fats
-
Allowing occasional refined carbs in moderation
-
Doing interval training 3X a week
The weight has come off at an average pace of 1-2 pounds per week, sometimes more, rarely less. I hit the odd plateau that required getting stricter for a bit before continuing downward.
But by giving myself FLEXIBILITY, I didn‘t self-sabotage, binge out of deprivation or totally lose sanity like my Phase 1 experience!
I also have a life again outside of dieting thanks to the more reasonable restrictions. And nutrients from fresh whole foods keep my energy levels stable so I can play with my kids and excel at work.
Could I have gotten faster results by rigidly sticking to Phase 2 of South Beach? Maybe, but I know myself. I would have cracked under the pressure and then faceplanted into a gallon of ice cream!
If you also tend to struggle with black-and-white, all-or-nothing dieting, I can‘t recommend strongly enough that you borrow what works for YOU from South Beach and scrap what doesn‘t.
Customize so you can actually envision eating this way forever as a lifestyle. That’s how you finally win at weight loss once and for all!
I hope my brutally honest South Beach experiment has shown that amazing transformations happen on a nonlinear path. As long as you get back up when you stumble, you’ll be amazed at how far you can go.
Stay consistent, be kind to yourself, make it work for your needs. You’ve so got this!
To making our health goals reality in 2024,
Mark
