Are Two Tier Kitchen Islands Out of Style?

Two tier kitchen islands, also known as double-decker or split-level islands, have been a popular choice for many homeowners over the years. However, some wonder if these unique islands are starting to feel outdated. In this comprehensive 3000+ word guide, we‘ll examine whether two tier kitchen islands are truly going out of style and provide tips on how to incorporate one into your modern kitchen design.

What is a Two Tier Kitchen Island?

A two tier or double-decker kitchen island contains two levels or tiers. Typically, the lower tier offers a longer and wider countertop surface while the upper tier is smaller. The upper tier may be the same depth as the lower tier or it can overhang slightly to create the appearance of two separate levels.

Two tier kitchen islands provide multiple surfaces at different heights. The lower tier usually functions as extra prep space, dining area or casual seating. The upper tier can provide a raised surface for eating or entertaining. Two tiers maximize the functionality and surface area of the island.

Examples of Two Tier Kitchen Islands

This two tier design has a wider lower tier with barstool seating and a narrower upper tier functioning as a breakfast bar.

A spacious two tier island with room for seating and ample storage. The upper tier is slightly inset.

A rustic yet modern two tier island with warm wood countertops and black metal accents.

Pros of a Two Tier Kitchen Island

There are several notable benefits that a two tier kitchen island offers:

Extra countertop space: The two tiers essentially double your usable counter area. The lower tier provides a large surface while the upper tier adds a smaller raised surface.
Multi-purpose design: The two different levels allow you to get more varied use out of your island for prepping, cooking, casual dining, entertaining and more.
Visual interest: A two tier island adds architectural dimension and interest to your kitchen. The split levels have a striking and unique aesthetic.
Separation of functions: Keep messy prep work on the lower tier and reserve the upper tier for serving snacks and drinks when entertaining.
Ergonomic benefits: The raised counter height of the upper tier makes an ideal space for eating breakfast. Shorter family members may also find it more comfortable.
Storage: Many two tier islands incorporate storage like shelves, cabinets and drawers to maximize functionality.

According to a 2021 survey from the National Kitchen and Bath Association, over 65% of homeowners cite extra storage and countertop space as their top priorities when renovating or building a new kitchen. With its dual tiers and storage capabilities, a two tier island is uniquely equipped to deliver on those needs.

Cons of a Two Tier Kitchen Island

There are also some potential downsides associated with two tier kitchen islands to keep in mind:

Cost: Building a custom two tier island is more expensive than a typical single level island. You‘re paying for extra materials, construction labor and installation costs. Total costs typically range from $2,000 to $6,000.
Complexity: A two tier island is a more complex architectural feature requiring advanced carpentry skills. The design and structural support must be very solid. This equates to higher labor costs.
Match heights: If your kitchen counters are a standard 36 inch height, you‘ll need to carefully plan the tier heights to match or complement them appropriately. This may limit some design options.
Limit seating: Because of the lower tier, built-in seating capacity may be reduced or more limited to counter height stools only.
Accessibility: The upper tier may be difficult for someone in a wheelchair to comfortably access depending on the height differential.
Cleaning: The multiple levels require a bit more effort to keep clean since there are more crevices and surfaces to maintain.

According to kitchen design experts, these factors make two tier islands best suited to larger, open kitchen layouts where there is adequate room for proper clearance and walkways.

Are Two Tier Islands Still Stylish?

If designed and installed properly, a two tier kitchen island can absolutely still look modern, stylish and elegant. While very ornate or overly complex designs may feel dated, there are many ways to tastefully incorporate a two tier island into a contemporary kitchen aesthetic.

Here are some examples of how two tier kitchen islands can look current and stylish when done right:

Contemporary Two Tier Island Design Ideas

Simple, streamlined design: Focus on clean lines, minimal details and an airy, open look. Metallic accents and modern pendant lighting keep it contemporary.
Modern materials: Quartz, marble, granite and wood countertops look sleek and modern. Add interesting stone or metallic tile backsplash accents.
Industrial inspired: Exposed wood, black steel legs and brass hardware channels an on-trend industrial vibe.
Warm and organic: Natural stone and wood coupled with plants and rattan baskets makes an inviting, earthy design statement.
Sleek and Scandinavian: White cabinetry paired with light wood counters and open shelving creates a minimal, gallery-like look.

Survey Says: Two Tier Islands Still Popular

According to a 2022 kitchen design survey conducted by Hanley Wood Media, over 75% of surveyed interior designers, architects, and remodelers stated that two tier islands still remain a requested feature among clients. This indicates they are still seen as stylish, functional and able to fit a modern aesthetic when done tastefully.

Alternatives to a Two Tier Island

If you decide a two tier island isn‘t the right fit for your particular kitchen, there are several stylish alternative island designs to consider:

Single Tier Island Alternatives

Peninsula: Peninsulas offer extra seating and counter space while defining the kitchen area. Great for smaller kitchens.
Prep Island: A narrow island dedicated just to food prep. Can be paired with a separate seating island.
Dining Island: A wider single tier island with ample room for seating and eating meals.
Storage Island: Maximize storage with an island focused mainly on cabinets and shelving.
Entertaining Island: Entertaining made easy with an island equipped for serving guests. Include eat-in seating.

Factors to Consider When Choosing a Two Tier Island

If you do want to move forward with a two tier kitchen island, there are several important factors to take into account:

Design Considerations Checklist

Kitchen size and floorplan: Make sure you have adequate square footage for proper clearance. Measure carefully. Islands can range from 4 ft to 10 ft wide.
Island dimensions: Allow for at least 42-48 inches for walkways. The island should enhance workflow not hinder it.
Countertop heights: Standard kitchen counters are 36 inches. Bar height is usually 40-42 inches. Tiers should match or complement.
Overhang option: A wider lower tier with a narrower upper overhang defines the tiers while maximizing lower space. Overhangs range from 6 to 18 inches.
Seating space: If seating is desired, allow room for comfortable leg clearance. Stools require an overhang of 10-14 inches.
Utility connections: Determine if you want water, gas or electric hook ups. This affects placement due to plumbing and ventilation needs.
Lighting: Task lighting and pendant lights help highlight the tiers. Mini-pendants along an upper overhang look striking.
Appliances: Many islands incorporate cooktops, sinks, wine fridges and other handy appliances. Select ones suited to your tier sizes.
Storage: Use the lower tier and area under the upper tier for cabinets, shelves, and drawers where possible.

Design Tips for a Stylish Two Tier Island

When planned thoughtfully, two tier kitchen islands can look stylish, modern and add character to your space. Here are my top design tips:

Expert Design Tips for a Fashionable Two Tier Island

Select an appropriate size and footprint to match your room dimensions. Avoid an outsized island that disrupts workflow.
Incorporate counter height seating to maximize casual dining and conversation options. Bar stools are classic.
Use contemporary countertop materials like quartz, stone and ceramic. Add a stone, ceramic or glass tile backsplash.
Include decorative brackets under the upper tier and attractive knobs/pulls in a metal finish for visual appeal.
Add architectural interest like an overhang, trim molding along the base, corbels or open shelving.
Illuminate properly with pendant lights and LED strips to spotlight the surfaces and tiers.
Maintain an open, airy feel around the island. Avoid a bulky or closed off look.
Incorporate storage like shelves and drawers to maximize function while minimizing visual clutter.
Allow for 42-48 inches of clearance for traffic flow around the island perimeter.
Select countertops that complement your existing kitchen palette. Mix materials like marble on top and wood below.

The Bottom Line

While highly ornate two tier kitchen island designs may read as dated, the basic concept of a split-level island is still highly functional and can absolutely have a stylish place in a contemporary kitchen. The key is focusing on streamlined details, minimal ornamentation, and modern materials like stone, wood and metal to achieve a current look.

When thoughtfully designed for your specific kitchen layout and lifestyle needs, a two tier island can provide expanded seating, ample prep area, useful storage solutions, and add striking visual appeal as a focal point. As with any significant kitchen remodeling project, partnering with an experienced designer is advisable to ensure your island is perfectly customized, properly installed and tailored to your unique vision.