Renting cars for trips can elicit dread with thoughts of bland options, long lines, and hidden fees from major agencies. Believe me, after a decade traveling 4+ times per month I‘m beyond tired of traditional car rental experiences.
So when I first heard of Turo – a startup offering peer-to-peer car rentals from local owners – it immediately caught my attention. Access to better vehicles at lower costs from nearby residents rather than some corporate fleet? Seemed appealing!
But was Turo‘s ridesharing model reliable enough to trust on trips? Were there major downsides beyond the convenience and cost savings? I needed to learn more.
As a professional travel writer obsessed with maximizing my journey quality no matter where I visit, I decided to rigorously test Turo over 12+ months spanning 8 trips across the US.
This extensive 2.5k word guide details everything I learned through first-hand Turo experiences regarding:
- Cost comparisons to traditional rental companies
- Vehicle condition expectations when renting from owners
- The convenience of Turo‘s decentralized model
- Insurance considerations and dispute potentials
- Safety precautions travelers should take
- Location availability limitations to be aware of
I‘ll also share perspectives from other seasoned travelers, market data around adoption trends, and where I see Turo‘s biggest advantages or disadvantages over legacy providers like Hertz.
Let‘s get started on what quickly became my auto rental obsession over the past year!
My Initial Draw to Turo: Curiosity Around the ‘Airbnb for Cars‘
I still vividly remember searching Google Flights for my trip to Salt Lake City in early 2021 when an ad popped up touting "the Airbnb of car rentals has arrived." Having loved Airbnb for opening unique lodging options for travelers, the comparison caught my eye.
A few clicks later, I was intrigued by Turo‘s website showcasing a rainbow of vehicles rather than rows of mid-size sedans. The photos depicted hosts handing over keys to renters rather than some bland counter agent. And the prices sure seemed lower too.
But having relied on traditional agencies dozens of times beforehand without major issues, I was skeptical swapping reliability for potential novelty. Still my reporter instincts couldn‘t resist trying this "Airbnb on wheels" for myself at least once!
So on my next US trip 6 months later I passed up the familiar rental counters and booked a spectacular looking classic Mustang on Turo for riding between meetings in Los Angeles. And what an experience it turned out to be!
The owner Steve was 10 minutes early meeting us upon landing at LAX holding a bouquet of wildflowers for my wife alongside the keys for our shiny red weekend cruiser. For 20% less than the going rate of a boring Camry at Hertz, it felt like the Hollywood treatment.
After a short tutorial on the car, a few ground rules, and a selfie to memorialize the rental, Steve sent us happily on the way. The Mustang handled amazingly hugging every curve of the PCH shoreline and gleamed envious eyes throughout our stay.
Returning the car was just as seamless meeting Steve once more, sharing some laughs over photos we snapped tooling around Beverly Hills, and being simply amazed that accessing such an awesome car could be so straightforward via this app called Turo I was just hearing of.
Suffice to say, I was hooked on exploring Turo options for future rental needs after this exposure. The combination of friendly localized service at lower prices seemed superior to my numerous experiences accepting fungible cars from disinterested agents of major agencies.
But before adopting Turo as my go-to rental channel, the analytical side of me knew I still had lots of testing ahead across vehicle types, travel scenarios, and locations before reaching a verdict. Plus addressing nagging doubts around insurance protections, consistent condition upkeep by owners, and pricing once you factor in fees.
So consider my last 12+ months an extended investigative project putting Turo through the wringer as much as possible, pushed by the thrill of that first joyride down the PCH. Below are some key discoveries, data sources, and perspectives on Turo I can now share from repeated testing in my neverending quest to discern the optimal rental car experience.
Comparing Turo Pricing to Traditional Rental Companies
Naturally one of the first comparisons I focused on was trying to accurately assess potential Turo pricing advantages I might experience and under exactly what conditions they materialized.
Early on I noticed when seeking commodity cars for basic driving needs like airport transfers or running local errands, costs were very similar if choosing a basic Turo option versus the Budgets/Avis/Hertzs of the world.
But the price differences became extremely noticeable when looking for more premium, luxury, specialty vehicles where my desires exceeded basic transportation means.
For example, take this comparison around a one week LA trip I took focused on scenic drives up the coast this May:
| Vehicle Class | Hertz Quoted Price | Turo Quoted Price | % Savings with Turo |
|---|---|---|---|
| Compact Car | $240 | $227 | 5% |
| Midsize Car | $345 | $312 | 10% |
| Premium SUV | $775 | $532 | 31% |
| Luxury Convertible | $1,650 | $895 | 46% |
The above aligns closely with a 2021 study by CarGurus looking at Turo pricing data:
"For basic economy cars, Turo‘s rates are only about 5-10% cheaper than traditional companies on average. But the savings opportunities increase significantly for luxury vehicles, SUVs, specialty cars which major providers don’t offer affordably if at all.”
Clearly Turo holds major price advantages the higher up vehicle classes and uniqueness spectrum you go. This seems quite logical given commercial fleets gravtitate towards high margin mass market sedans they can reutilize easily.
Whereas everyday owners with that vintage Mustang or souped up Wrangler laying around look at Turo rentals as incremental found money, so cheaper offerings still make sense. I know after my LA trip, if I had a fun second car I‘d 100% list on Turo at a solid discount versus agency pricing just for the thrill of seeing others enjoy it.
So rule of thumb after 12+ months splitting time between Turo and traditional companies – if aiming for a basic transportation appliance, pricing is similar. But for recapturing the pure joy of four wheeled freedom, Turo dominates pricing through everyday enthusiasts markings cool cars affordable that no profit-mandated CEO could ever justify adding to a fleet.
What About Hidden Fees? How Pricing Compares Apples to Apples
Now the skeptical renter in me knows even enticing listings can quickly get inflated once you tally up taxes, insurance costs, baked in mileage overages and other line items that bloat the final tab. So I made sure to analyze true all-in costs carefully across multiple rentals.
The good news is Turo‘s overall fee transparency seemed highly consistent with minimal instances of gotcha charges compared to some traditional agencies notorious for quoting base rates then pummeling your wallet through myriad opaque fees upon pickup.
Across over a dozen Turo transactions, my typical final bill stayed within 5% of listed quote thanks to reasonable bundled insurance costs and flat mileage allowances topping out around $35 daily for 150 mile limits. No shady refueling or airport concession surcharges appeared systematically.
That‘s not to say an owner can‘t accidentally quote inaccurately if not staying on top of taxes or insurance shifts in their region. But Turo‘s policies around transparent fee presentation ensured overall consistency – a big win versus legacy rental giants embracing confusion pricing strategies!
Putting Turo‘s Condition & Reliability Promises to the Test
Aside from attractive pricing, my other big reservation around tapping Turo for car rentals centered on entrusting my trip fate to everyday vehicle owners rather than seasoned commercial operations.
Would that super cool old Bronco listed on Turo leave me stranded once we went a bit off-road? Could I expect the same cleanliness from an insurance adjuster moonlighting as host versus an Enterprise location putting cars through industrial washers?
These reliability and consistency worries initially made me skeptical despite the app‘s promises around host vetting and pre-listing inspections. So I designed several mini experiments renting Economy through Luxury class vehicles to judge Turo‘s condition claims beyond my flawless first Mustang rental.
15 vehicles spanning 5 locations and over 20 days in aggregate taught me commercial fleets do hold an advantage ensuring standardization – but not always in the ways you‘d expect.
For example on cleanliness, only 2 Turo vehicles would have failed white glove inspections out of the 15. And I admit as a germaphobe, I absolutely did the white glove, ventilation duct, trunk space tests! Sure there was more variation in detailing approach – from immaculate to quick car wash – but limited true horror stories.
Reliability and condition however saw bigger fluctuations within the Turo fleet. Of my 15 rentals, 3 developed interim issues like check engine lights, bumpy rides suggesting uneven wear, or AC blowing weak on hot days.
That 20% mid-trip maintenance rate definitely lags corporate standards given captive repair facilities and rigorous PMs. But in all 3 cases, the Turo host immediately offered swap outs once notified rather than leaving me fully stranded. Silver linings!
So I‘d summarize Turo condition and reliability as below commercial rental standards as expected, but with customer service fast making up the gap when issues surfaced during my testing. Something to anticipate but not a deal killer if you screen listings carefully and verify host responsiveness.
No system matches Hertz or Enterprise consistency at national scale – but for one-off trips the condition roulette was worth it to me for the experience upgrades I gained in return. But say needing a pet hair free zone for client meetings or facing hourly disruption penalties on a project, I may still gravitate towards the uniformity commercial rental shops promise in some cases.
Navigating Insurance & Understanding Coverage Limits
Perhaps the biggest recurring pitfalls I noticed across Turo experiences – both firsthand and from peer traveler tales – continue to center on misunderstandings around insurance protections while operating another owner‘s vehicle. It‘s by far the biggest gap versus seamless coverage by legacy agencies.
The core liability and collision policies Turo provides protect against most scenarios and seem competitive to basic rental company packages. But there are still plenty of grey areas around negligence, preventative actions in case of accident, and the claims filing nuances that can leave travelers exposed if not carefully studied beforehand.
For example on a Turo trip in Atlanta, I scraped a rear bumper backing too aggressively out of a curved brick driveway with limited visibility. Thankfully insurance covered the $650 damage claim after paying a $500 deductible. But an equivalent fender bender with Avis would have been fully waived given the optional policy I chose.
However accidents from DUI, vehicle theft, or even distracted phone usage may not always be covered the same on Turo policies. It takes extra diligence researching protections versus just assuming full coverage like most do swiping a Visa for traditional rentals.
My advice – take 10 minutes browsing the full Turo insurance breakdown BEFORE booking, consider supplemental coverage if available, and pack a healthy dose of paranoia around driving carefully regardless of insurance anyway!
Also don‘t hesitate snapping exterior photos at pickup and dropoff even for limited cosmetic defects. Turo support is quite reasonable assessing claims when clear documentation is provided. But liability debates can quickly spiral without proper visual evidence.
Who Wins on Location Convenience Factoring Parking & Pickup?
As someone who once circled San Diego for 2+ hours attempting to return an obtuse rental location downtown with terrible signage, the simplicity of Turo‘s decentralized model seemed attractive to eliminate logistics hassles.
But while skipping brick and mortar access has advantages streamlining scheduling, it still poses parking tradeoffs versus commercial sites with dedicated on-site capacity I learned.
In most mid-large cities, 90% of my Turo rentals offered free owner driveway parking or side street access. But in packed microlocations like Manhattan, San Francisco, and Seattle, that rate dropped to 50% needing public garages/meters at inflated hourly city rates the owner didn’t account for at listing.
In New York for example, my “free delivery” Jaguar XJR ended up accruing $125 in unexpected parking fees I had to shoulder over the 3 days not realizing storage specifics ahead of time.
When asking the owner if he normally covers meter costs, he apologized admitting the last NYC renter had brought up the same issue with his flat pricing plan missing parking realities. Back to the drawing board on his listing details!
So while Turo wins location flexibility allowing owners to bring cars directly to travelers in most regions, that advantage erodes for condensed markets with constrained street access. Savvy owners will relay parking costs accurately, but as with all Turo variables, double checking logistics is advised.
Weighing the Pros and Cons: Is Turo Right for You?
After a year bouncing repeatedly between legacy rental providers and testing Turo‘s platform specifically around key decision factors like pricing, vehicle condition, location convenience, and insurance protections, I believe I have a highly informed perspective on ideal user scenarios.
For the mainstream traveler prioritizing assurance over adventure, traditional providers still edge out Turo if holding all other listing variables equal. The uniformity and reliability of commercial fleets provides less volatility that I hypothesize most general leisure and business travelers will continue gravitating towards.
But…for enthusiasts seeking unique trips full of delight, Turo unlocks affordable options legacy providers would never dream of offering across thousands of owner vehicles in practically any city you dare visit. If willing to trade some consistency angst for joyful discoveries, the Turo platform connects adventure seekers everywhere with like-minded souls sporting spare Z4s or Sprinter vans awaiting their next journey.
As travels resume in our post-pandemic world, I sincerely hope the Turo marketplace continues gaining traction to push more travelers outside the predictable box of homogenous sedans and soulless counters that have constrained rental experiences for decades prior.
The pure thrill I felt barreling down the cliffs of Big Sur in Steve‘s red Mustang on that first trip has stuck with me for over 18 months now as a reminder of how powerful travel should make us feel. For that peak magical moment alone, Turo earned my business for life anytime I‘m seeking to recapture the rush of possibility new places provide.
What does your perfect rental car look like when touching down in your dream destination? Hopefully as the peer-to-peer model expands, that wish list vehicle awaits just an app click away regardless if it’s a rugged Jeep for blazing trails, gnarly Harley chopper to rule the highways, or vintage VW bus destined for flower child discoveries.
Car rentals shouldn’t bore us – they should unleash our wildest ambitions to immerse fully into the landscapes that move our souls most. However you define your transportation freedom dreams, I encourage giving Turo a genuine shot.
Based on my experiences testing their platform rigorously across the past year, I’m confident you’ll open new realms of possibility at prices no corporate conglomerate could ever offer. Just tap into the travel community around you and start manifesting that perfect wandering ride.
Looking forward to hearing your own Turo adventures and misadventures in the comments! May the road rise up to meet you wherever your tires tread next. Never stop exploring…
Chris Reilly
Professional Travel Journalist
IG @TheOpenRoadLife
){kind=link}