As an avid fitness enthusiast with over 10 years of experience trying all kinds of in-studio and at-home workout programs, I’ve developed some clear opinions on what works best. Recently, two brands ruling the world of on-demand digital fitness caught my attention – Peloton and Beachbody. Both have seemingly compelling offerings, but have some critical differences too.
If you’re looking to kickstart your own fitness journey from the comfort of your home, you’re probably curious to learn more about these popular options. Well, you’ve come to the right place!
Having extensively tested both Peloton and Beachbody workouts across various programs and equipment, I’ve put together this detailed comparison review to help uncover which is BETTER suited for your specific fitness needs and preferences.
Let’s get started!
A Quick Overview of Peloton and Beachbody
For some fast facts on both platforms:
Peloton
- Founded in 2012 in NYC by John Foley
- Offers live and on-demand digital fitness classes across categories like cycling, running, bootcamps, strength training, yoga etc
- Requires purchase of Peloton equipment like their bikes and treadmills for some class types; other classes use your own gear or none
- Over 10,000 classes with variety across class length, difficulty, training style etc
- Known for their motivational trainers and highly engaged community features
Beachbody
- Founded in 1998 by Carl Daikeler & Jon Congdon
- Extensive library of over 1,500 workouts spanning programs like INSANITY, 21 Day Fix, P90X etc
- Structured programs focused on areas like HIIT, strength, dance, yoga etc.
- No need for any special equipment – use what you already have at home
- Meal plans and nutritional guidance bundled with certain packages
- Community support through online groups and message boards
So in a nutshell – Peloton is perfect when you want guided daily workout variety while Beachbody is great for following structured programs fused with dietary advice. But which one delivers better RESULTS? Let‘s analyze some key dimensions in this Peloton vs Beachbody comparison:
Workout Quality and Training Style
With access to thousands of classes led by motivating world-class trainers, Peloton clearly wins when it comes to workout quality and sheer variety. I loved the energy and encouragement from Peloton instructors that inspired me to push harder and perform better. Whether I wanted a short 15 minute HIIT routine or a 60 minute yoga flow class, there were plenty of options matching my needs.
The classes strike a perfect balance between getting your heart rate up but also prioritizing proper form and technique throughout. And with multiple class difficulty levels, they work equally well for beginners and seasoned pros alike.
Over my 3 months using Peloton so far, I‘ve never felt bored because of the diverse class plans trainers come up with. They combine cardio, strength training and core conditioning beautifully into creative flows. I‘ve literally tried a new kickass total body workout every single day!
Now Beachbody programs are formulated quite well too – but they stick to a fixed structure over multiple weeks. So while you‘ll certainly get results following the plan through with discipline, it does get repetitive. I did try both INSANITY and P90X programs before moving to Peloton. And frankly, neither kept me consistently motivated after the initial few weeks once the novelty wore off.
If you love routine and need strict guidance though, Beachbody plans will suit you better. The trainers are still top-notch showing moves safely with lots of form cues. Just don‘t expect a huge variety unless you combine multiple programs.
Winner – Peloton offers superior training quality and style owing to the daily class variety and phenomenal instructors.
Accessibility and Equipment Requirements
Peloton markets a range of top-notch (but steeply priced) fitness gear like bikes and treadmills ranging $1445 to $2845. However, I realized DIY hacks like hooking your own spin bike with toe cages to the Peloton tablet works nicely too! This opens up lots of accessibility since you don‘t need to buy their proprietary (and let‘s face it – overpriced) equipment necessarily.
Additionally, Peloton offers several bodyweight only workouts or programs compatible with basic items found at home like light dumbbells, a yoga mat, resistance bands etc. By using what I already had for strength, yoga and bootcamp classes, I saved a bundle – with the same intensity I’d get in a boutique studio class!
Now with Beachbody, the entire focus lies on making at-home fitness more accessible to the masses. None of the programs need fancy equipment – all can be done with minimal gear like dumbbells, a bench and so on. The workouts are thoughtfully designed to leverage household items easily available.
So if budget is a constraint, Beachbody certainly wins on the accessibility front hands down. Peloton works best when you already have basic gear or can invest in their products. At under $2000 a pop, the Peloton bike for instance is certainly not affordable for most people.
Winner – Beachbody takes the cake for making at-home fitness achievable for wider audiences by using basic gear people already own.
Motivation and Community Support
As an inherently social person, community features deeply influence how effectively I stick to any wellness habit long term. Both Peloton and Beachbody facilitate motivation via online groups but go about it differently.
The gamified features on Peloton simulating real classes set it apart for me. Seeing the leaderboard and metrics of other members during cycling classes triggered my competitive instincts to pedal harder! I also loved getting shoutouts from instructors mid-class after hitting key milestones, making me feel recognized. Beyond classes, the challenges and social feed where you share your wins and commentary really makes you feel part of a close-knit community.
I‘ll admit – after over 5 years being a Beachbody coach and loyalist, I was certain NO other platform could trump their community and accountability levels. But by enabling rich engagement DURING an actual class alongside the content, Peloton has revolutionized digital fitness for good.
That said, the online groups and forums of Beachbody still work well for discussing programs, diets and struggles outside class times. So if you need tons of supplementation through chat forums, resources etc. then Beachbody helps. For pure motivation DURING workouts specifically, Peloton all the way!
Winner – Peloton edges ahead with their game-changing features fostering motivation and connectivity spanning pre-workout, during classes, post-workout and beyond.
Nutrition and Meal Planning Support
I’ve come to realize fitness results involve two key ingredients – proper training AND nutrition. Now Peloton unquestionably dominates on the workout quality piece with their ever-growing library led by elite trainers. However, they DO lack in offering meaningful nutrition guidance to complement programs.
This is where Beachbody pulls ahead by bundling supplementary meal planning support spanning recipes, cheat sheets, grocery lists and more. For instance, the FIXATE cookbook and portion control containers solutions that come with Beachbody plans offer invaluable diet assistance.
After following the standardized FIXATE recipes while completing my first round of 21 Day Fix 8 years back, I actually achieved my weight loss targets so much faster compared to winging nutrition solo before. Having a roadmap containing specifics on what foods to eat, ideal macros and calories to aim for removed all guesswork.
And I continue leveraging the color coded portion control containers system to balance nutrients and meal sizes even today – they work like magic! So if you feel YOU specifically need a crash course in healthy meal prepping and planning assistance from experts, Beachbody has your back.
Peloton remains laser focused on just fitness sans diet support. So bring your own healthy eating game or be ready to figure the nutrition piece out through trial and error.
Winner – For first timers wanting an all-in-one fitness and health package, Beachbody is a saver with the meal guidance bundled in. Peloton purely provides world-class training minus any diet help.
Pricing Considerations
Given how much value either platform provides in terms of physical, mental and health gains – the pricing feels well justified to me for both Peloton and Beachbody. But let‘s still examine this dimension closely.
The Peloton app costs a flat fee of $12.99 monthly (or $9.99 monthly with a bike/tread purchase) granting unlimited access to all classes. This felt like an absolute steal to me given the sheer quality and variety! No strings attached and cancel anytime making it flexible.
The pricing gets steeper with the actual Peloton hardware like their flagship Bike priced at $1445 and Tread treadmill for $2495. Financing options spread payments over monthly installments making high-end gear more accessible. But unless you plan on near daily use, going the affordable DIY hardware route works reasonably well too.
Comparatively, Beachbody app pricing has more tiers spanning $39 quarterly, $59 semi-annually or $99 annually for complete library access .The cost drops but commitment extends as you go longer. Plus packages bundling workout AND nutrition support range from $160 to $380 yearly.
So purely just app access feels pricier for Beachbody given the annual layout. Bundles covering nutrition and Shakeology drinks feel worthwhile for newbies wanting immersive guidance. But not relevant otherwise given the recurring cost.
Ultimately Peloton stole my heart with their fair flat-fee model granting ultimate flexibility. Caveat is the optional equipment cost being excessively high.
Winner – Peloton app provides better overall value with cheaper access and flexibility on a monthly basis. But equipment bumps up costs unless you improvise with your existing infrastructure.
Getting Started With Free Trials
The best part about both platforms? Generous trial periods allowing you to validate whether the style of training and community meets your preferences!
Peloton App offers a 30 days free period – extremely useful to browse all content extensively before subscribing. I was able to browse SO many classes spanning cycling, HIIT and even meditation during my trial. It convinced me thoroughly that investing in Peloton long-term could accelerate my fitness.
Likewise with Beachbody, you get 14 days of full access across their mammoth library. I recommend using the trial by following just ONE complete 30 or 60 min program instead of randomly sampling workouts. Doing the full INSANITY Fit Test routine gave me a taste of their ultra intense training style. And I knew instantly whether it matched my fitness and recovery capacity before signing up.
So do spend this risk-free duration for both platforms wisely to gauge if the training and community support works for you. Classes that look cool but turn monotonous quick or felt too advanced for your level right now would surface during this phase. So don‘t rush the buying decision before testing thyself first!
Winner – Tie! The free trial for both platforms is generous enough to ascertain suitability and aligns perfectly to your preferences and level.
Peloton vs Beachbody – The Final Verdict based on YOUR Needs!
Now for the biggest question – which option should YOU pick and will benefit you the most?
Well, it depends primarily on 3 key factors:
-
Desired Variety vs Structure: Peloton if you like exploring new styles daily or Beachbody for regimented fitness programs
-
Level of Equipment: Peloton for hardcore gear heads willing to splurge; Beachbody for households with just basic mats and dumbbells
-
Value of Meal Guidance: Beachbody if you are a complete fitness and nutrition rookie; Peloton when you already follow a fairly clean diet
Beyond these 3 aspects, also reflect on how much you value community features, pricing, accessibility etc. before deciding.
Personally for me, Peloton was undoubtedly the platform that kept me constantly challenged and engaged with their ever-evolving class variety led by stellar trainers. My DIY hacks around equipment also made it feasible cost-wise. And I didn’t really need nutrition support being fairly informed on my diet fundamentals already. So it proved the ideal match aligning to ALL my preferences clearly.
But your fitness priorities may be different based on your current abilities, gear availability, budget and lifestyle. So think hard and choose what resonates MOST with your personal goals. After all, the best workout program is one you will actually STICK to long term!
If it still feels overwhelming evaluating between Peloton vs Beachbody, I have the PERFECT suggestion. Why not try maximizing the free trials offered by both generously? Put each platform through a suitable “test workout” matching your usual style done at high intensity. See which training format, instructor vibe and community features you naturally gravitate more towards.
Let the platforms that WOWS you through the trial period win! Having taken both for an extensive spin myself now, I’m confident you’ll discover your ideal fit liking one experience a clear notch over the other.
So stop overanalyzing and go TEST real-time instead! Just set a reminder to cancel unwanted subscriptions before getting auto-billed post the trial. With this fail-proof fitness matchmaking strategy, I guarantee you’ll have ZERO regrets on the digital training partner you ultimately commit to for the long haul!
You’ve got this! Now let me know in comments if this Peloton vs Beachbody comparison helped shape your decision in ANY way!
