Inactive subscribers and stagnant email lists – the bane of any email marketer‘s existence. You pour your heart into crafting valuable emails week after week, only to see your open rates slowly dwindle and your list engagement flatline.
Sound familiar? You‘re in good company. According to Mailchimp‘s email marketing benchmarks, the average email open rate across industries is just 21.33%. That means nearly 4 out of 5 subscribers aren‘t engaging with the average email!
What‘s more, email lists naturally decay by about 22.5% every year as subscribers‘ addresses change, their interests evolve, and your emails get lost in the shuffle of overflowing inboxes.
But fear not, frustrated email marketer. Your inactive subscribers aren‘t a lost cause. With a strategic re-engagement campaign, you can revive even the most stagnant email list and get your subscriber relationship back on track.
In this ultimate guide, we‘ll equip you with the tools and tactics you need to successfully re-engage your inactive subscribers and bring your dead email list back to life in 2024 and beyond. Roll up your sleeves and let‘s get to work!
Understand the Reasons for Email Disengagement
Before we dive into specific re-engagement strategies, let‘s take a moment to understand why subscribers disengage in the first place. There are a multitude of reasons why a once-active subscriber might start ignoring your emails:
-
Your content is no longer relevant to their needs or interests. As subscribers‘ lives and careers evolve, so do their content preferences. If you‘re not keeping pace with their changing needs, they may lose interest.
-
You‘re emailing them too frequently. If you‘re bombarding subscribers with multiple emails per day or week, they may start tuning you out to preserve their sanity. A 2022 HubSpot survey found that 35% of respondents prefer to receive marketing emails 1-3 times per month.
-
Your subject lines aren‘t compelling. If your subject lines are generic, misleading, or just plain boring, subscribers may not feel motivated to open your emails. In fact, 47% of email recipients decide whether to open an email based on the subject line alone.
-
Your emails are getting caught by spam filters. If your emails contain spammy trigger words, too many images, or other red flags, they may be getting diverted to subscribers‘ spam folders before they even have a chance to engage.
-
They‘re just too dang busy. Let‘s face it, we‘re all drowning in email these days. Sometimes, even the most valuable and relevant emails get lost in the shuffle of overflowing inboxes.
By understanding the factors that contribute to email disengagement, you can craft a re-engagement strategy that addresses subscribers‘ core issues and objections head-on.
Reconnect with a Segmented Re-Engagement Campaign
Ready to plan your re-engagement campaign and start winning back those inactive subscribers? The first step is to segment your list and tailor your messaging accordingly. Not all inactive subscribers should receive the same re-engagement sequence.
Consider segmenting your inactive subscribers into buckets like:
-
Recently inactive (no opens/clicks in 3-6 months). These subscribers likely just need a gentle nudge and reminder of your value to regain their engagement.
-
Moderately inactive (no opens/clicks in 6-12 months). For subscribers who haven‘t engaged in half a year or more, you‘ll need to work harder to recapture their attention and earn back their trust.
-
Chronically inactive (no opens/clicks in 12+ months). If a subscriber hasn‘t engaged with your emails in a year or more, it‘s time for a bold move. Pull out all the stops with high-value offers and incentives.
-
Engaged but not purchasing. If subscribers are opening and clicking your emails but not converting into customers, they may need more education, social proof, or special offers to nudge them down the purchase path.
By tailoring your re-engagement messaging to subscribers‘ specific level of inactivity and past behavior, you can deliver the most relevant, effective content to each cohort.
Once you‘ve segmented your inactive subscribers, it‘s time to build out your re-engagement email sequence. Here‘s a sample flow for a 4-email re-engagement series:
Email 1: Remind Them Why They Subscribed
- Restate your email list‘s value proposition and mission
- Highlight your best content and offers
- Tell subscribers what they‘ll gain by staying engaged
- Tease an exciting announcement or gift coming next email
Email 2: Deliver a High-Value Opt-In Incentive
- Provide a free ebook, course, template pack, or other lead magnet
- Make the offer uber-relevant to subscribers‘ goals and pain points
- Reiterate the value prop and show them what‘s to come
Email 3: Invite Feedback and Preferences
- Ask subscribers what kind of content they want to receive
- Invite them to update their email preferences and frequency
- Include a survey to gather insights for improving your emails
- Offer a discount code or "comeback" coupon for your products
Email 4: Last Chance to Stay Subscribed
- Tell subscribers it‘s their last chance to stay on your list
- Remind them of all the value and benefits they‘ll lose
- Provide one final free resource or downloadable goodie
- Make it stupid-easy to click and stay subscribed
Throughout your re-engagement sequence, focus on crafting ultra-compelling, can‘t-help-but-click subject lines. Subject lines with 6-10 words tend to have the highest open rates, so keep things clear and concise.
Some examples of click-worthy re-engagement subject lines:
- "We Miss You! Here‘s 20% Off to Come Back"
- "[Name], Do You Still Want to Hear from Us?"
- "Freebie Inside: Our Best [Resource] of the Year!"
- "Should We Break Up? Final Chance to Stay on Our List"
Remember, your re-engagement campaign is your chance to sell your subscribers on the value of continuing to hear from you. Don‘t be afraid to get creative, try new tactics, and put your best foot forward.
Keep the Conversation Going
Congratulations! Your re-engagement campaign was a success and you‘ve brought a solid portion of your inactive subscribers back into the land of the living. Now it‘s time to keep the momentum going and ensure those subscribers stick around for the long haul.
The key to a thriving, engaged email list is consistently delivering relevant, valuable content that subscribers can‘t wait to receive. That means committing to:
-
Regular email frequency. Whether it‘s once a week or once a month, pick an email cadence you can maintain consistently and stick with it. 80% of marketers send email newsletters 1-2 times per month.
-
Quality over quantity. Resist the temptation to churn out emails just for the sake of keeping up with your schedule. If you don‘t have something valuable to say, it‘s better to skip a send than to bombard your list with fluff.
-
Continuous list hygiene. Regularly clean your email list to remove bounces, unsubscribes, and chronically inactive subscribers. Keeping your list lean and clean protects your sender reputation and ensures maximum deliverability.
-
Personalization and dynamic content. Use your email marketing platform‘s personalization and segmentation features to deliver hyper-relevant content to each subscriber. Personalized emails deliver 6X higher transaction rates.
-
A/B testing and optimization. Continuously test subject lines, content, offers, and calls to action to fine-tune your email strategy. Even small tweaks can yield big gains in engagement.
-
Engaging visual design. Make your emails a pleasure to read with a clean, on-brand visual design that includes plenty of white space, interesting images, and a mobile-friendly layout.
By committing to email marketing best practices and continuously improving your strategy, you can keep your re-engaged subscribers coming back for more.
Wrapping Up
Inactive subscribers and dead email lists don‘t have to mean the end of your email marketing program. With a strategic approach and a commitment to delivering real value, you can revive even the most comatose list and get your subscriber engagement thriving again.
As you plan your re-engagement campaign, remember:
- Understand the reasons why subscribers disengage in the first place
- Segment your inactive subscribers and tailor your messaging accordingly
- Craft a re-engagement sequence that reminds subscribers of your value, provides a high-value incentive, invites feedback, and makes a compelling last-chance offer
- Write click-worthy subject lines that stand out in the inbox
- Continue delivering consistent value to keep subscribers engaged for the long haul
With email marketing, slow and steady really does win the race. The ROI of email marketing is an incredible $36 for every $1 spent. By investing in your email list and treating your subscribers like the VIPs they are, you can tap into the long-term revenue and relationship-building power of this tried-and-true channel.
You‘ve got this, email marketer. Here‘s to bringing those inactive subscribers back from the dead and building an email list that‘s the envy of your industry. Happy sending!
