As your resident baking buddy, I get asked this question all the time! Are melting wafers and chocolate chips the same thing? Can you use them interchangeably? What‘s better for baking vs candy making? Not to worry, I‘ve done the research so we can settle this debate once and for all.
Grab your apron and let‘s get cookin‘! We‘ll uncover the differences between these two tasty ingredients so you know exactly when to use each one.
Melting Wafers – Smooth, Sweet, and Versatile
Melting wafers, also called confectionery wafers or candy coatings, are a top choice for candy making, drizzling, and decorating. These smooth discs melt quickly at low temps and come in a huge range of colors and flavors.
Melting wafers are made from a blend of vegetable oils, sugar, milk products, cocoa butter, emulsifiers, and other ingredients. According to an industry report by ResearchAndMarkets.com, the global melting wafers market reached $3.6 billion in 2021 and is projected to grow steadily in the coming years.
Popular melting wafer brand Merckens relies on palm kernel oil, coconut oil, soybean oil, and cocoa butter for their recipe according to their website. Companies like Make‘n Mold use partially hydrogenated palm oil along with less than 2% cocoa butter.
Why are vegetable oils used? They allow the wafers to melt smoothly at temperatures between 85-90°F. Melting wafers become entirely liquid at low temps, perfect for detailed candy work. They also eliminate the need for tempering, unlike real chocolate.
When to Reach for Melting Wafers:
-
Candy Making – Their easy melting and thin consistency are perfect for dipping fruit, pretzels, nuts, and more. Melting wafers create smooth, professional-looking candies.
-
Drizzling – Drizzle melted wafers over cakes, cupcakes, and other treats. Their fluidity allows you to drizzle intricate designs.
-
Chocolate Molds – Melting wafers flow evenly into silicone molds to capture intricate details. Reviews on Michaels.com praise how well melting wafers work for chocolate molds.
-
Fondue Fountains – The smooth texture prevents clogging issues in fountains. Melting wafers also harden quickly when set out to create a nice coating.
-
Decorations – Pour melting wafers into shapes or use like "glue" to assemble gingerbread houses. Their quick-setting properties keep decorations neat.
-
Colors and Flavors – From chocolate to strawberry to butterscotch, melting wafers offer limitless flavor and color options. Get creative with your drizzles and designs!
Now you can see why melting wafers are a candy maker‘s best friend! Their versatility, easy meltability, and array of options make them perfect for decorative sweet treats.
Chocolate Chips – The Baking Essential
Chocolate chips, also called morsels or baking chips, are a must-have for cookies, cakes, muffins, and more. Unlike melting wafers, chocolate chips are made from some combination of chocolate liquor, cocoa butter, milk products, sugar, and emulsifiers.
The Cacao Barry website states their chips contain 35% cocoa butter, while the Guittard website reports a 36% cocoa butter content in their popular chips. These higher percentages result in an indulgent chocolate taste and texture.
The global market for chocolate chips was $3.23 billion in 2021 according to Mordor Intelligence, showing their popularity for baking. Common types of chocolate chips include semisweet, bittersweet, milk chocolate, and white chocolate.
Reach for Chocolate Chips When:
-
Baking Cookies – The thicker shape prevents excessive melting and spreading. Chips add delicious pockets of chocolate.
-
Making Cakes or Brownies – Chips add bursts of chocolate when baked into cakes, brownies, blondies, and more. Their high fat content keeps them moist.
-
Trail Mixes – Chocolate chips pair perfectly with dried fruit, nuts, seeds, and cereals in homemade or store-bought trail mixes.
-
Ice Cream Add-Ins – Stir chocolate chips into ice cream for delicious frozen treats. The chilling temperature keeps them firm.
-
Snacking – With their rich chocolate flavor, chips are an indulgent snack straight from the bag!
For baking and snacking, chocolate chips can‘t be beat. Their distinctive flavor and ability to hold shape during baking make them a universally loved ingredient.
Melting and Texture Show the Difference
When it comes to melting, chocolate chips and melting wafers behave very differently. Let‘s compare:
Melting Wafers
- Melt completely at 85-90°F
- Smooth, pourable consistency when liquid
- Flow easily into molds and coatings
- Set up glossy and opaque for a professional appearance
Chocolate Chips
- Melt between 90-93°F
- Retain a grainy, chopped texture when melted
- Thicker consistency makes pouring difficult
- Don‘t fully melt if cooked or baked
Chocolate authority and pastry chef Stella Parks notes that chocolate chips are formulated not to "overmelt" when baked into cookies. This allows them to hold their shape instead of melting into a puddle in the oven.
When solidified, melting wafers have a smooth, even sheen compared to chocolate chips‘ drier, matte appearance. Melting wafers deliver professional results for candy making while chocolate chips perform better in the oven.
Ingredients Impact Flavor
Let‘s compare the ingredients behind both products:
Melting Wafers
- Vegetable oils – Provides smooth texture but little flavor
- Sugar – Adds sweetness
- Cocoa butter – Minor amounts for texture
- Milk solids – Typically absent
- Flavorings/extracts – Boost flavor due to lack of cocoa butter
Chocolate Chips
- Chocolate liquor – Made from roasted cacao beans; provides true chocolate flavor
- Cocoa butter – High content gives an indulgent, creamy melt
- Sugar – Balances and enhances chocolate flavor
- Milk solids – In milk chocolate chips for a creamier profile
- Natural vanilla – Accentuates chocolate notes
Since they lack cocoa butter, melting wafers have a weaker chocolate taste. Their flavor is considered "subtler and more nuanced" according to Hershey‘s guidelines. Chocolate chips owe their signature flavor to cocoa butter, chocolate liquor, and minimal adulteration.
Shelf Life – The Fresher, the Better
Let‘s keep these tasty ingredients tasting their best! Proper storage is key for maximizing shelf life.
Melting Wafers
- Last 6-12 months
- Prone to "chocolate bloom" – whitish coating from poor storage
- Store tightly wrapped in cool, dry place
- Refrigerate or freeze for best quality
Chocolate Chips
- Last 1-2 years
- Store in cool, dark pantry
- Ideal temperature under 68°F
- Keep tightly sealed in original bag
The high fat content of cocoa butter makes chocolate chips more shelf stable. Melting wafers made with vegetable oils deteriorate more quickly. Always check package dates and recommendations – fresher is better!
Baking Substitutions? Proceed with Caution!
While you may be tempted to swap between melting wafers and chocolate chips in recipes, beware – the results can be iffy. Here‘s my advice:
Substituting Melting Wafers for Chocolate Chips
- Cookies may spread thinner and over-bake
- Wafers may "melt out" and leave empty pockets
- The flavor will be weaker and overly sweet
Substituting Chips for Melting Wafers
- May not melt smoothly, giving a thick, lumpy texture
- Tempering is required for candy making
- Rich flavor may overwhelm other ingredients
To improve results if substituting, I suggest:
- Add a bit of shortening to chips when melting them
- Reduce oven temp by 25°F if using wafers in place of chips
- Use semi-sweet chips rather than dark for candy recipes
- Opt for drizzling vs pouring chips into molds
While in a pinch you can sub one for the other, for best results I recommend using the ingredient specified. Their unique qualities make them better suited for certain recipes.
Melting Wafers or Real Chocolate – Which is Best?
My advice? Let the recipe and intended use guide you. Both offer unique advantages.
For baking – go for chocolate chips. Their distinctive chocolate flavor and ability to hold shape during baking can‘t be beat.
For detailed candy production and decorations – melting wafers excel. Their fluid melting, bright colors, fun flavors, and no-temper convenience provide gorgeous, professional results.
For snacking – personal preference rules! Both offer indulgent flavor in an easy-to-eat form. Choose your favorite and chow down!
Now that we‘ve explored the differences between melting wafers and chocolate chips, I hope you feel confident deciding when to use each one. Let me know if you have any other baking or candy questions! I‘m always happy to help.
Happy baking and candy making, friend!
