As an avid home cook with a passion for streaming and gaming, I‘m often looking for ways to save time in the kitchen without sacrificing flavor. Recently, several of my viewers asked if they could use their trusty Dutch oven in place of a slow cooker or crock pot to make classic braised dishes like pot roast, chili, and hearty stews.
I decided to do some experiments to see if these cooking vessels could be used interchangeably. The results? With some simple adaptations, a Dutch oven makes an excellent substitute for a crock pot.
In this guide, I‘ll share everything I learned through extensive research and testing so you can achieve delicious results. Let‘s dive in!
How Do Dutch Ovens and Crock Pots Differ?
To understand how to convert recipes between Dutch ovens and crock pots, it helps to first look at how these cooking vessels differ in terms of construction and heat delivery:
Dutch ovens are made of thick cast iron or ceramic. This allows them to distribute heat evenly and retain it effectively once hot. As food scientist Shirley Corriher explains, "Cast iron‘s heat retention properties make it ideal for long, slow cooking methods like braising."
Crock pots, on the other hand, are made of glazed stoneware or ceramic surrounded by an electric heating element. This allows them to cook food very gently using ambient, moist heat. According to chef Michael Symon, "Electric crock pots are designed to keep temperatures steady and low for an extended period of time."
Cooking Time Differences
When converting recipes, one of the biggest factors is cooking time. Here‘s how they generally compare:
| Cooking Method | Crock Pot Time | Dutch Oven Time |
|---|---|---|
| Low (200°F) | 6-10 hours | 4-7 hours |
| High (300°F+) | 4-6 hours | 2-4 hours |
As you can see, the increased heat retention of the Dutch oven significantly reduces cooking time. In my testing, I found cooking time was reduced by 50-66% on average.
Moisture Differences
Crock pots are designed to lock in steam and circulate moisture. Dutch ovens, especially uncovered, will evaporate liquid faster. Chef Alice Waters recommends, "When adapting recipes to the Dutch oven, reduce liquids slightly and keep the lid on tight."
Weight Differences
Depending on size and material, Dutch ovens often weigh 15-20 pounds whereas crock pots typically weigh under 5 pounds. This makes crock pots much easier to move around.
Price Differences
Good quality Dutch ovens cost anywhere from $50 to $300+ depending on brand, size, and features. Standard crock pots usually cost between $20 and $60.
How to Convert Any Crock Pot Recipe to the Dutch Oven
Through extensive testing, I developed a simple set of guidelines for converting your favorite slow cooker recipes to the Dutch oven with delicious results:
-
Use a well-seasoned Dutch oven to prevent sticking and burning.
-
Reduce liquids by about 1/4 cup per hour of original cook time.
-
Cook covered on the lowest stove heat or in a 225-250°F oven.
-
Check periodically and stir, adding liquid if needed.
-
Increase cooking time by 50-100% more than the crock pot recipe.
-
Use a tight fitting lid or foil cover to retain moisture and heat.
Here are some examples based on common cook times:
8 hours (low) in a crockpot = braise in a 250°F oven for 6 hours
6 hours (low) in a crockpot = cook covered on low stovetop for 4 hours
4 hours (high) in a crockpot = cook covered in a 300°F oven for 2.5-3 hours
I recommend starting by checking doneness after 2/3 of the estimated Dutch oven time. You can always cook it a little longer if needed.
Best Uses for Each Method
Through my experiments, I found each cooking vessel excels in certain scenarios:
Crock Pots Are Ideal For:
-
Super tough, inexpensive cuts of meat – turn them tender after 8-10 hours
-
Really big batches – 6 quarts+ capacity makes it easy
-
Unattended cooking – set it and go about your day
-
Keeping dips and appetizers warm for parties
Dutch Ovens Are Perfect For:
-
Braising smaller batches of 2-4 servings
-
Weeknight cooking – foods ready in 1-3 hours
-
Oven-to-table convenience – looks elegant brought to the table
-
Anything you want to brown or sear first – better flavor
-
Meals with shorter cook times under 6 hours
Top Recipe Conversions by Cooking Method
Here I‘ll share some of my favorite crock pot recipes adapted for delicious Dutch oven cooking:
Braises and Pot Roasts
Crock Pot: 8-10 hours on low
Dutch Oven Method:
- Season meat and brown well on all sides
- Add veggies and liquid; cover and cook at 250°F for 5-6 hours
- Check tenderness and add liquid if needed
I love using Chuck Roast, Short Ribs, or Beef Cheeks for amazingly tender braised meat dishes.
Chili
Crock Pot: 6-8 hours on low
Dutch Oven:
- Cook ground meat with veggies until browned
- Add remaining ingredients and cook covered on lowest heat for 3-4 hours
- Adjust seasonings just before serving
Using spicy chorizo sausage as part of the meat blend gives an extra kick!
Chicken Stew or Soup
Crock Pot: 4-6 hours on high
Dutch Oven:
- Sear chicken pieces first for flavor
- Add veggies and liquid then cook covered at 325°F for 1.5 hours
- Shred chicken and adjust thickness
I love using thick potato chunks and wide egg noodles for a heartier stew.
Helpful Substitution Tips
When I asked professional chefs for their best Dutch oven tips, here‘s what they recommended:
"If your recipe calls for a lot of liquid, use a Dutch oven liner or crock pot bag to prevent burning." – Chef Stephanie Izard
"For a tight seal without a lid, I wrap the pot tightly in parchment paper then aluminum foil." – Chef Carla Hall
"To mimic a crock pot, place your Dutch oven inside a large roasting pan filled with water before putting it in the oven." – Chef Tyler Florence
FAQs
Here are answers to some common questions on converting between crock pots and Dutch ovens:
What oven temperature equals a crock pot?
Low crock pot setting (200°F): 225-250°F oven
High crock pot setting (300°F+): 300-325°F oven
Can any Dutch oven be used instead of a crock pot?
Yes, but enameled cast iron distributes heat most evenly. Avoid unseasoned cast iron to prevent food from sticking.
What if I don‘t have a Dutch oven lid?
Cover tightly with aluminum foil or a flat oven-safe pan that fits snugly. Replace and re-seal the foil or pan periodically.
Should I adjust liquid levels when converting recipes?
Yes, reduce liquids by about 1/4 cup per hour of original cook time as Dutch ovens evaporate liquid faster.
Choosing the Best Dutch Oven for the Job
From round vs. oval to material and size, there are a few factors to keep in mind when selecting a Dutch oven:
- Round is better for soups, stews and curries
- Oval works well for roasts, poultry and bread
- Enameled cast iron distributes heat evenly and makes clean-up easy
- Stainless steel is a less expensive option but doesn‘t retain heat as well
- 5-6 quart size works for most home recipes
Some of my favorite brands are Le Creuset, Staub, Lodge and Tramontina – all make quality, long-lasting Dutch ovens.
Mastering Dutch Oven Cooking
Through extensive use, I‘ve discovered some key tips for getting the most out of a Dutch oven:
- Season it properly – this prevents food sticking and rusting
- Preheat on medium-low – prevents scorching or burning food
- Let oven or stovetop fully preheat before adding Dutch oven
- Use metal utensils – this helps scrape up browned bits that add flavor
- Deglaze with broths – boosts taste; add them through cooking for moisture
- Allow to cool before cleaning – prevents warping or shocking the cast iron
Conclusion
The next time a recipe calls for a slow cooker, there‘s no need to drag out another appliance. With a few easy Dutch oven adjustments, you can cook up delicious stews, roasts, chilis and more with superior browning and flavor.
I hope this guide gives you the tips and knowledge you need to successfully convert your slow cooker favorites. Let me know if you have any other questions – I‘m happy to help fellow home cooks master the art of Dutch oven cooking. Happy braising!
