Vintage vs Antique: Understanding the Differences, Value, and Allure

For those who love the thrill of the hunt and the joy of living with pieces of the past, the world of antiques and vintage is a rich landscape to explore. But navigating that landscape requires an understanding of what distinguishes an antique from a vintage piece, and how to assess the value and rarity of each. In this guide, we‘ll delve into the fascinating history behind these terms, reveal how to identify and date older objects, and provide expert insight on collecting, preserving, and investing in antiques and vintages.

The Evolving Definitions of Antique and Vintage

The terms "antique" and "vintage" have meanings that have shifted over time. Tracing their etymology provides a foundation for understanding their current usage.

"Antique" has its roots in the Latin word "antiquus," meaning old or ancient, and came into English usage in the 16th century. Initially, it simply referred to something that was very old. But as global trade expanded in the 18th century and more ancient objects entered the market, the term narrowed to mean items from ancient Greece, Rome, Egypt, etc. By the late 19th century, as the production and consumption of goods accelerated, antique began to be used more broadly again to refer to objects at least 100 years old.

The 100-year definition was formalized in 1930 with the Smoot-Hawley Tariff Act, which set import duties for "antiques" as items 100+ years old, distinguishing them from newer "collectibles." In 1966, the standard was adopted by the US Customs Service. But today, many dealers consider objects 80+ years old to be antiques to avoid a glut of inventory from the 1940s. Age parameters continue to evolve.

Meanwhile, the word "vintage" comes from the French "vendage," meaning grape harvest, and originally referred only to the yield of wine from a specific year or vineyard. By the early 20th century, it had expanded as an adjective to describe something classic, enduring, and high-quality, often evoking nostalgia. Think of a "vintage" car or the "vintage" of a person‘s character.

Over the last few decades, vintage has become the go-to term for objects too young to be antique but too old to be current, generally falling between 20-100 years old. Some define vintage more narrowly as 40-100 years old, with 20-40 year old objects dubbed "retro." The lines are fuzzy. A general rule of thumb is that antiques are valued for their historical significance, while vintages are prized for their cultural currency. But there is plenty of overlap.

Identifying Antiques: Clues from Style, Material, and Marks

Antiques from different historical periods have distinct looks that can help date them. Here are some key eras in furniture styles:

Gothic (1200-1450): Pointed arches, dark wood, heavy & architectural
Rococo (1700s-1760s): Curved shapes, floral details, gold gilding
Neoclassical (1760s-1830s): Straight lines, Greek/Roman motifs, brass inlays
Victorian (1837-1901): Ornate, eclectic, renaissance of past styles
Art Nouveau (1890-1910): Curving lines, nature-inspired elements

Antique furniture was handcrafted from solid wood, showing imperfections, natural graining, and shrinkage. Genuine antiques are never made of particle board, laminate, or faux materials. Look for hand-hammered nails, irregular joints, and wood pegs.

Upholstery fabrics like silk, velvet, and needlepoint were expensive and rare. Horse hair, hay, and sawdust were used as stuffing before synthetic foam.

Check for maker‘s marks, patents, and hallmarks stamped on furniture, silver, jewelry and ceramics. Look on the underside and inside drawers. Antiques may show signatures of individual craftsmen.

Use reference books or online guides like Kovels‘ Antiques & Collectibles Price Guide or WorthPoint to compare your piece to known antique examples. Consult an appraiser for high value items.

Spotting Vintage: Hallmarks of 20th Century Style

Vintage pieces reflect the aesthetics and innovations of 20th century design movements:

Art Deco (1920s-1930s): Bold geometric shapes, glossy finishes, exotic woods
Bauhaus (1920s-1930s): Functionalist, tubular steel, minimalist, primary colors
Mid-Century Modern (1940s-1960s): Organic curves, teak & walnut, pop art hues
Space Age (1960s-1970s): Plastic, fiberglass, modular, futuristic silhouettes
Postmodern (1970s-1990s): Avant garde, unpredictable shapes, bright colors

Vintage furniture often features plywood, bent wood, plastics, and laminates not seen in antiques. Look for machine-precise construction and hardware like zippers and Velcro.

Vintage garments were mass-produced with standard sizing, labels, and synthetic materials like polyester, acrylic and spandex. Identify vintage fashion by researching styles, designers, and labels from each decade:

1920s: drop waists, tiered skirts, T-strap shoes
1930s: bias cuts, backless gowns, platform wedges
1940s: tailored skirt suits, fitted sweaters, peep-toe pumps
1950s: circle skirts, shirt dresses, kitten heels
1960s: miniskirts, shift dresses, go-go boots
1970s: bell bottoms, peasant blouses, platform shoes
1980s: power suits, neon spandex, high-top sneakers

Use guides like The Vintage Fashion Bible or Vintage Fashion Guild‘s Label Resource to identify and date clothing, accessories and textiles.

Assessing Value: What Makes an Antique or Vintage Piece Collectible?

The antique and vintage market is significant and growing. In the US alone, the resale market is expected to reach $64 billion by 2024, a 39% increase from 2019. Online antique and vintage sales platforms like 1stDibs, Chairish, and Etsy are booming.

But what makes one antique vase or vintage handbag more valuable than another? Seasoned collectors consider:

Rarity: How many were made and how many survived? Mass-produced pieces tend to be less valuable than one-of-a-kinds or limited editions.

Authenticity: Is the provenance documented? Are there receipts, certificates, or expert appraisals? Beware of reproductions posing as antiques.

Condition: Is the item mint, good, fair or poor? Damage, repairs, and missing parts detract from value. Rare items may have value despite flaws.

Craftsmanship: Does the piece showcase exemplary materials, techniques and artistry of its era? Quality endures over quantity.

Desirability: Is the item currently in vogue? What‘s fashionable for collectors fluctuates over time. Pieces featured in museums or major collections set trends.

In 2019, the top-selling antiques at auction included a Chinese porcelain vase from the Ming Dynasty ($500,000), a rare Paul Newman Rolex Daytona watch ($437,500), and a mid-1800s Imperial Russian malachite table ($212,500).

Record prices for vintage 20th century designs include $3 million for a Patek Philippe perpetual calendar watch from 1943, $1.6 million for a 1962 Ferrari 250 GTO car, and $1 million for an original 1950s Barbie doll.

Of course, most antique and vintage acquisitions fall modestly below those headline-grabbing prices. Peruse price guides, auction results, and dealer listings to gauge the market rate for particular collectibles. Consider an item‘s backstory and your personal connection to determine its worth to you.

Antique & Vintage Hunting: Where to Find Treasures

Half the fun of collecting antiques and vintages is the quest to find them. Seasoned collectors scour:

  • Estate sales & auctions
  • Flea markets & swap meets
  • Thrift stores & charity shops
  • Specialty antique stores & centers
  • Online marketplaces & forums
  • Garage & yard sales

No matter the venue, examine items thoroughly for condition issues, maker‘s marks, and signs of authenticity before buying. Ask plenty of questions and request documentation for high-ticket items.

"Buy what you love. The thrill of the hunt is in finding that special something that speaks to you, that you connect with on an emotional level," advises vintage jewelry collector Danielle Miele of Gem Gossip. "My best finds have come when I‘ve taken chances on pieces that caught my eye, even if I didn‘t know exactly what they were. The research and learning that comes after is part of the fun."

Antique furniture expert Bob Richter, host of the PBS series Market Warriors, cautions against quick flips based solely on perceived value. "People get so focused on what something is worth that they strip out all the history and soul that drew them to the piece in the first place. I say, collect what will bring you joy to live with. If it later sells for a profit, that‘s a bonus, but it shouldn‘t be the only end goal."

Collecting Antiques and Vintages: Preserving the Past

Whether your passion is for antique curiosities or vintage fashions, collecting older objects is both a privilege and a responsibility. As a collector, you become a steward of history, preserving the craftsmanship and stories of earlier eras.

Different materials require different care to maintain their integrity. Antique wood furniture should be regularly dusted with a soft cloth, waxed yearly, and kept out of direct sunlight which can fade finishes. Avoid modern cleaning products that may damage old patinas.

Antique upholstery and vintage clothing are best stored in a cool, dark place with even humidity to prevent mold and mildew. Use acid-free tissue paper and archival boxes for storage, and never hang vintage garments on wire hangers which may rust and distort shoulder seams.

"When you fall in love with an antique or vintage piece, you‘re assuming the role of curator. It‘s up to you to honor the artisans and history behind the object and ensure it survives to enchant the next generation," says antiques care expert Scott Haskins of Fine Art Conservation Laboratories. "Proper storage, handling, and maintenance are essential. So is documenting the piece‘s story for posterity."

Before attempting any repairs on antiques or vintages, consult a professional restorer. Well-intended DIY fixes like gluing a broken vase or mending a torn garment can cause further damage and torpedo value if done improperly.

"Embrace imperfection," advises Miele. "A flaw is not always a deal breaker and can even add to an object‘s charm and backstory. The French call it ‘beaut√© du temps‘ — the beauty of time. Loving and living with an antique or vintage piece means appreciating the journey it took to get to you."

The Enduring Allure of the Old

In a world of rapid changes and disposable trends, antiques and vintages offer a tangible connection to the past and a more sustainable approach to consuming. Collecting them is a way to invest in quality over quantity, to appreciate artistry and history, and to cultivate personal style.

"There‘s a depth of character and craftsmanship to older pieces that you just don‘t find in much of today‘s mass-produced merchandise," says Richter. "When you buy an antique or vintage item, you‘re not just purchasing an object, but a story, a legacy. It‘s a way of integrating yourself into the continuum of history."

As you build a collection that reflects your taste and values, you also gain entry into a community of fellow enthusiasts who share your reverence for the past. Collecting opens doors to new knowledge, experiences, and relationships.

"Antiques and vintages bring people together in the spirit of discovery, creativity, and preservation," says Haskins. "Whether scouring shops together or showing off your latest finds, collecting facilitates interactions across generations and keeps historical mementos in circulation."

In the end, the true value of an antique or vintage piece lies in its meaning to you. It‘s in how it enriches your home, enlivens your imagination, and deepens your engagement with the vast arc of human creativity across centuries. That connection and inspiration is, itself, a timeless treasure. One worthy of pursuit and preservation as you become part of the storied legacy of collecting.

How useful was this post?

Click on a star to rate it!

Average rating 0 / 5. Vote count: 0

No votes so far! Be the first to rate this post.