Whether displayed on a shelf or used to season meals, salt and pepper shakers are a familiar sight in most homes. But for passionate collectors, certain antique salt and pepper sets are cherished treasures – and may be worth a small fortune. The most coveted shakers marry beauty, craftsmanship and history, with the rarest examples commanding thousands at auction.
So what separates a run-of-the-mill set from one that makes seasoned collectors salivate? As a long-time antiques appraiser specializing in tableware, I‘m excited to share my knowledge of the most valuable salt and pepper shakers and tips for identifying the real deal. Join me on a journey from the Victorian dining table to the modern auction block as we explore these small wonders.
A Dash of History: Salt & Pepper Shakers Through the Ages
The use of salt cellars dates back to ancient times, but salt and pepper shakers as we know them didn‘t emerge until the early 18th century. The earliest shakers were made from precious metals like silver, reflecting the high cost of salt and pepper at the time.
As salt became more affordable in the Victorian era, mass production of shakers ramped up to meet demand from the growing middle class. Silver-plated sets remained popular but less expensive materials like glass and ceramics also came into use. Novelty designs shaped like figures, animals and objects emerged as manufacturing innovations allowed.
The 20th century saw the introduction of new materials like plastic and stainless steel and an explosion of different styles, with shakers reflecting the design trends of each decade. While these more recent sets are often collectible, antique shakers from the 18th, 19th and early 20th centuries are generally the most valuable due to their age, rarity and level of craftsmanship.
The Holy Grails: 15 of the World‘s Most Valuable Antique Salt & Pepper Shaker Sets
These 15 salt and pepper shaker sets are among the most coveted and valuable in the world. While not an exhaustive list, it showcases the diversity of designs and materials found in high-end antique shakers.
1. Meissen Porcelain Figurines – Circa 1880
Estimated Value: $10,000+
Meissen porcelain is prized by collectors for its exceptional quality and artistry. This rare set features a male and female figure in 18th century attire with exquisite detailing, showcasing the German company‘s mastery of hard-paste porcelain.
2. Paul Storr Silver Drum Shakers – 1813
Estimated Value: $8,000-$10,000
Famed Georgian-era silversmith Paul Storr created this elegant neoclassical set shaped like drums and adorned with lion head handles and paw feet. Few Storr shakers remain in existence, making them highly sought after.
3. Russian Enamel & Silver Gilt Shakers – Circa 1900
Estimated Value: $7,500+
These Russian shakers feature intricate cloisonne enamel designs in vibrant colors set in ornate silver gilt holders. The superb workmanship and material richness exemplifies the artistry of the pre-revolutionary era.
4. Tiffany Sterling Silver Figural Shakers – Circa 1875
Estimated Value: $6,000-$7,000
Leave it to Tiffany & Co. to elevate the humble salt and pepper shaker to a work of art. This charming figural set depicts a boy and girl in sterling silver, with incredible detailing in their clothing and facial expressions.
5. English Porcelain Asparagus Shakers – Circa 1755
Estimated Value: $5,000+
These rare asparagus-shaped porcelain shakers showcase the whimsy and creativity of early English porcelain. Believed to be made by the Chelsea porcelain factory, they feature delicate painted leaves and stalks forming the handles.
6. Japanese Satsuma Earthenware Shakers – Meiji Period (1868-1912)
Estimated Value: $4,000-$5,000
The Satsuma pottery tradition is known for its milky glaze and intricate painted gilt designs. This gourd-shaped set featuring scenes from Japanese folklore and life exhibits the height of artistry from the Meiji period.
7. American Cut Glass Shakers by Dorflinger – Circa 1915
Estimated Value: $3,000-$4,000
American cut glass reached its zenith in the "Brilliant" period from 1876-1917, with Dorflinger being one of the most prominent makers. This set features the intricate Venetian pattern with a silver overlay, exemplifying the opulence of the era.
8. Wedgwood Jasperware Portrait Medallion Shakers – 19th Century
Estimated Value: $2,500-$3,500
Josiah Wedgwood‘s signature blue jasperware lent itself beautifully to neoclassical designs. This set features white portrait medallions set in pale blue jasperware with acanthus leaf borders, epitomizing Wedgwood‘s style.
9. Gorham Silver and Cobalt Glass Shakers – 1920s
Estimated Value: $2,000-$2,500
These Art Deco shakers by Gorham combine sterling silver and deep blue glass for a striking effect. The angular, geometric design captures the luxury and glamour of the Roaring Twenties.
10. Black Americana "Mammy & Chef" Shakers – 1940s
Estimated Value: $1,500-$2,000
While controversial today, Black Americana kitchenware was popular in the early-mid 20th century. This set depicting stereotypical "mammy" and chef figures is rare to find in good condition and represents an uncomfortable part of America‘s past.
11. Georg Jensen Acorn Shakers in Sterling Silver – 1930s
Estimated Value: $1,200-$1,500
Danish silversmith Georg Jensen is renowned for his organic Art Nouveau designs. These acorn-shaped sterling shakers showcase his nature-inspired aesthetic rendered in gleaming silver.
12. Victorian Aesthetic Movement Silver Plate Shakers – 1880s
Estimated Value: $800-$1,200
The Aesthetic Movement celebrated artistic design and these silver-plated shakers embody that ideal. With their elongated forms, stylized bird motifs, and mixed metals, they exemplify the Anglo-Japanese style popular at the time.
13. Staffordshire Pottery Cow Shakers – Circa 1875
Estimated Value: $600-$800
Animal-shaped shakers were a Victorian novelty and cows were an especially popular subject. This set, crafted in English Staffordshire pottery, features realistically sculpted and hand-painted cattle.
14. Depression Glass "American Sweetheart" Shakers – 1930s
Estimated Value: $400-$500
Depression glass is prized for its delicate beauty and represents resilience during hard times. This cube-shaped set in the iconic "American Sweetheart" pattern with its sweeping scrolls was made by MacBeth-Evans Glass Company.
15. Jadeite "Ball" Shakers by Fire-King – 1940s-50s
Estimated Value: $200-$400
The bright green glass known as Jadeite is a staple of Mid-Century kitchenware. This set of ball-shaped Jadeite shakers was produced by Fire-King and is coveted by collectors for its color and retro style.
Tips for Identifying Authentic Antique Salt & Pepper Shakers
With antique shakers being so valuable, reproductions and fakes abound in the market. Here are some key things to look for to ensure you‘re getting the real deal:
-
Maker‘s marks: Genuine antique shakers will often have a maker‘s mark stamped on the bottom indicating the company or artist. Research what marks to expect for a given maker and period.
-
Material indicators: Shakers made from early plastics like Bakelite or celluloid, which predate modern polymers, can indicate authentic vintage pieces. For metals, look for tarnish, patina and realistic signs of age.
-
Craftsmanship clues: Slight irregularities and asymmetry in hand-crafted pieces are to be expected, as opposed to the uniformity of modern mass production. Uneven glaze distribution is another hallmark of older ceramic and pottery shakers. Seams and bubbles in glass can also indicate pre-1950s manufacturing.
-
Use wear: Genuine antique shakers should show realistic signs of use like fading, minor chips, worn plating or spots of corrosion consistent with their age. Items that look "too new" may be cause for suspicion.
Of course, the best way to ensure authenticity is to purchase from a reputable antiques dealer who can provide documentation and guidance.
Where to Find Authentic Antique Salt & Pepper Shakers
If you‘re ready to start or expand your collection, there are many ways to acquire genuine antique salt and pepper shakers:
-
Antique shops and malls: Visiting antique dealers in person allows you to examine the shakers firsthand and benefit from the seller‘s expertise. Building a relationship with knowledgeable dealers is invaluable.
-
Online marketplaces: Sites like 1stDibs, Ruby Lane, and Etsy provide access to antique shakers from verified sellers worldwide. Read item descriptions carefully, study photos, and don‘t hesitate to ask questions before buying.
-
Auction houses: Both local auction houses and major firms like Christie‘s and Sotheby‘s can be excellent sources for antique shakers. Attending previews lets you view the items in person, and many auctions now offer online bidding as well.
-
Estate sales: Estate sales can offer wonderful opportunities to uncover antique treasures, including salt and pepper shakers, at more reasonable prices than retail settings. Arrive early for the best selection.
-
Antique shows and flea markets: Both large antique expos and local flea markets bring together multiple dealers, making them great places to shop for shakers. Take time to browse and compare offerings.
Caring for Your Antique Salt & Pepper Shaker Collection
To preserve the beauty and value of your antique shakers, handle them with care and display them in a place safe from accidental knocks. Avoid displaying in direct sunlight, which can cause fading, and wipe gently with a soft cloth to remove dust.
Before using antique shakers with salt and pepper, ensure there are no cracks or weaknesses that could lead to damage. For shakers used regularly, a gentle hand-washing with mild soap and prompt drying can keep them clean without abrading the finish.
Shakers made from silver, silver plate, or pewter will tarnish over time and benefit from periodic polishing with a non-abrasive polish safe for that metal. A light coating of mineral oil can help forestall tarnish as well. For any shakers with gold or painted details, refrain from polishing those elements to avoid wearing them away.
Valuing Your Antique Salt and Pepper Shakers
Valuing antique salt and pepper shakers depends on many factors including age, rarity, material, condition, and design. Shakers with precious metals, intricate enameling, or figural designs tend to command high prices.
Condition is especially critical to value, with mint condition examples fetching exponentially more than those with cracks, chips or other significant flaws. However, some signs of age like tarnish, light crackling, or minor wear are expected and can even enhance the appeal of an antique piece.
Maker also plays a major role in the value of antique shakers. Sets by famed silversmiths like Paul Storr or popular potteries like Wedgwood will be more valuable than pieces by lesser-known or anonymous makers.
Rarity is another key determinant of value, with unusual designs, uncommon materials, and limited production runs elevating the price of antique shakers. Rare survivors from the 18th and early 19th centuries will generally be more valuable than later examples.
To arrive at an accurate valuation for your antique salt and pepper shakers, consult a professional appraiser who specializes in silver, glass, ceramics, or the material your set is made from. They will be able to provide a fair market value based on current collector demand and recent auction prices for comparable pieces.
The Joy of Collecting Antique Salt & Pepper Shakers
Whether you‘re drawn to sleek Art Deco designs or charming Victorian animals, collecting antique salt and pepper shakers offers an endlessly fascinating pursuit. These diminutive objects speak volumes about craftsmanship, creativity, and the culture of dining through the ages.
As you expand your collection, take time to appreciate the artistry and history embodied by each set. Display them proudly, knowing you are preserving a small piece of the past for future generations. Happy collecting!
