The Most Valuable Charmander Pokémon Cards (Rarest Worth Up to $50,000)

As one of the original and most beloved starter Pokémon, it‘s no surprise that Charmander and its mighty evolved forms Charmeleon and Charizard are some of the most popular and sought-after Pokémon cards for collectors. While not all Charmander cards are equally rare or valuable, there are a select few printings and editions that can command astronomical prices on the resale market.

Whether you pulled a shiny Charmander card back in the early days of the Pokémon Trading Card Game (TCG) and are wondering what it might be worth now, or you‘re an avid collector on the hunt for the most elusive Charmander variants to complete your collection, this guide will walk you through the most valuable Charmander Pokémon cards and what makes them so highly prized.

What Makes a Charmander Card Valuable?

The value of a Charmander Pokémon card depends on a combination of factors:

Card Age/Set: In general, Charmander cards from the earliest Pokémon TCG sets like Base Set, Jungle, and Fossil tend to be more valuable than later printings due to age and scarcity. First Edition and Shadowless cards from these sets are especially desirable.

Rarity: Within each set, cards are assigned different rarity levels. Charmander cards that are "Secret Rare" or "Ultra Rare" with special holofoil designs or artwork are much harder to pull from booster packs and thus more valuable than common non-holo cards.

Condition: To be truly valuable to collectors, an old and rare Charmander card must also be in pristine condition. Professional grading companies like PSA grade cards‘ condition on a 1-10 scale, with a perfect "Gem Mint 10" card being significantly more valuable than even a "Mint 9."

Misprints/Errors: In some cases, a Charmander card that was misprinted with an error or unusual defect can actually be more valuable due to its uniqueness. These include cards with miscut edges, crimped or off-center printing, missing ink, etc.

With these factors in mind, let‘s look at some of the single most valuable Charmander cards ever sold.

The 5 Rarest & Most Expensive Charmander Cards

1. 1999 Pokémon Game #46 Charmander 1st Edition Base Set PSA 10 – $50,000

The holy grail for Charmander collectors, this is the very first Charmander card from the original 1999 Base Set, graded a perfect PSA 10 Gem Mint. With only 52 PSA 10 First Edition Charmander cards in existence and the iconic status of the original set, this is arguably the most desirable Charmander card available.

One of these flawless vintage beauties sold for $50,100 on eBay in December 2020 at the height of the Pokémon card collecting boom fueled by nostalgia and celebrity influencers. Base Set Charmanders in lower grades can still sell for impressive sums, with PSA 9s fetching over $1000.

1999 First Edition Base Set Charmander PSA 10

2. 2003 Pokémon Skyridge #146 Crystal Charmander Holo PSA 10 – $25,100

The 2003 Skyridge set introduced the visually stunning Crystal Type Pokémon cards, some of the most beautiful and desirable cards ever made. The crystal holofoil pattern is integrated into the Pokémon artwork itself rather than as a background. Skyridge was also the last set printed by Wizards of the Coast before Pokémon USA took over the TCG.

With only 26 Gem Mint PSA 10 copies as of 2023, the Crystal Type Charmander is extremely rare and highly coveted by collectors. A PSA 10 sold for $25,100 on eBay in July 2021.

2003 Skyridge Crystal Charmander PSA 10

3. 2003 Pokémon Dragon Frontiers Charmander Gold Star Holo #100 PSA 10 – $20,100

Gold Star Pokémon are some of the most iconic and beloved cards among collectors, featuring unique artwork on a shimmering gold holofoil background and identified with the special gold star symbol next to the card number.

The Dragon Frontiers Charmander Gold Star Holo is especially hard to find in PSA 10 Gem Mint condition, with only about 50 in existence. In January 2021, a PSA 10 sold for $20,100 on eBay.

2003 Dragon Frontiers Charmander Gold Star PSA 10

4. 2016 Pokémon XY Evolutions Charmander Toys ‘R‘ Us Holo #11 PSA 10 – $5,600

One of the more affordable cards on this list, the 2016 XY Evolutions Toys "R" Us exclusive holo promo featuring Charmander is still very popular and valuable due to the Black Star promo rarity and the 1999 Base Set artwork on a modern card.

While raw copies can be found for under $50, a PSA 10 graded copy sold for $5,600 on eBay in May 2021. This shows how much of a premium pristine condition can add.

2016 XY Evolutions Charmander Toys R Us Holo Promo PSA 10

5. 2021 Pokémon OCG SR 25th Anniversary Collection Charmander #4 PSA 10 – $4,700

To celebrate the 25th anniversary of Pokémon in 2021, a special anniversary collection was released with unique border designs and artwork. A PSA 10 graded copy of the Secret Rare Charmander from this set recently sold for $4,700 in January 2023.

This shows the ongoing demand for rare Charmander cards even from modern sets. Perfect condition graded copies will likely only increase in value over time as the anniversary set becomes harder to find sealed.

2021 25th Anniversary Collection Secret Rare Charmander PSA 10

How to Value Your Charmander Card

Think you might be sitting on a five-figure Charmander card? The first step is identifying exactly which card you have by set name, number, and edition (First Edition, Shadowless, Unlimited, etc). Check for any misprints or error marks as well.

Next, evaluate the card‘s condition honestly. Is it pack fresh with sharp corners and no whitening or edge wear? Use a jeweler‘s loupe or magnifying glass to check for surface scratches. Most serious collectors these days prefer cards graded by reputable companies like PSA, BGS, SGC, or CGC which encapsulate the card in a tamper-proof case with a numbered label.

If you determine you have a card that is rare and in good condition, look up recent verified sales on marketplaces like eBay to get a sense of fair market value. Condition is everything, so focus on sold prices for cards in similar shape to yours.

Where to Buy & Sell Valuable Charmander Cards

When buying high-value Charmander cards, always purchase graded copies from reputable sellers. eBay is the largest marketplace with the widest selection. Verify the seller‘s feedback history and sales of similar items. For raw (ungraded) cards, only buy from trusted specialists.

If selling your Charmander card, auction houses like Heritage Auctions, Goldin, and PWCC specialize in six-figure Pokémon cards and have a collector base willing to pay top dollar for the rarest examples in the best condition. For more affordable cards, eBay and TCGplayer are the top marketplaces.

Charmander Card Values Outlook

Pokémon card collecting shows no signs of slowing down, especially for iconic characters like Charmander. Values for the rarest cards in top grades have climbed significantly in recent years as deep-pocketed collectors battle for the best examples.

While condition is critical, Charmander cards have a sentimental appeal that goes beyond just rarity. Many fans have fond childhood memories of the adorable fire lizard Pokémon and its prominence in the original games, anime, and TCG. This emotional resonance should provide enduring demand.

As time passes, the earliest vintage Charmander cards from the late 1990s and early 2000s will only become harder to find in pristine condition, likely driving values for high grade examples even higher. Even more recent prints like the 25th Anniversary Collection could appreciate considerably over the long term.

Whether you‘re a new collector or a long-time Pokémon fan, Charmander cards offer both nostalgia and strong investment potential. While not every Charmander card will pay for your retirement, the most elusive and best preserved could light up your collection.

How useful was this post?

Click on a star to rate it!

Average rating 0 / 5. Vote count: 0

No votes so far! Be the first to rate this post.