Keeps vs Rogaine: In-Depth Review on Effectiveness, Pricing & More

Understanding Hair Loss Treatment Options

Hair loss can be distressing, but there are solutions available. The two most popular options on the market are Keeps and Rogaine. But how do you decide which one is right for you?

This in-depth guide will compare Keeps and Rogaine on the following aspects:

  • How each treatment works
  • Product options
  • Effectiveness
  • Cost and value
  • Convenience
  • Side effects
  • What customers have to say

Read on for the full keeps vs rogaine review.

How Does Keeps Work?

Keeps provides customized treatment plans for hair loss, consisting of oral medications finasteride and/or minoxidil.

Finasteride is a prescription pill that blocks DHT, an androgen hormone linked to pattern baldness. By reducing DHT in your system, finasteride allows hair follicles to recover.

On the other hand, minoxidil is applied topically to the scalp. It works by improving blood circulation around hair follicles and may cause hairs to grow thicker and longer.

With a Keeps subscription, you‘ll receive a customized mix of finasteride and/or minoxidil based on your hair loss needs. You‘ll also get ongoing access to licensed doctors, progress tracking, and more.

What About Rogaine?

The active ingredient in Rogaine treatment is minoxidil. As mentioned above, minoxidil promotes blood flow and thickens individual hairs.

Rogaine offers men’s and women‘s products with 2% and 5% minoxidil concentrations. The men‘s extra strength formula claims to grow up to 50% more hair than using minoxidil alone.

Their proprietary Tricho-Prime technology combines the vasodilator minoxidil with botanicals and exfoliating ingredients. Applied to the scalp, it works to reawaken hair follicles and stimulate growth.

Rogaine is an over-the-counter topical treatment that does not require a prescription. But unlike Keeps, it does not include other medications like finasteride.

Rogaine vs Keeps: Product Line Comparison

Keeps

Keeps sells hair wellness products in three main categories:

  • Hair loss treatments – Oral finasteride and topical minoxidil
  • Hair growth supplements – Nutrafol Men and Women
  • Hair products – Thickening shampoo, volumizing conditioner and more

Treatment plans start at $23 per month, including medication, doctor consultations, and progress tracking. Members can fully customize their regimen with add-ons.

Rogaine

Rogaine is focused specifically on FDA-approved minoxidil solutions:

  • Men’s Rogaine – Foam and liquid with 5% minoxidil
  • Women’s Rogaine – Foam, liquid, and mousse with 2% minoxidil
  • Rogaine for Beards and Mustaches – Foam with 5% minoxidil

Prices range from $30 to $100+ depending on formula and supply amount. The company also sells accessories like applicator tips and hair fibers for concealing thin spots.

Rogaine‘s product selection is more limited. But its specialty in minoxidil allows them to perfect and advance their patented formula.

How Effective Are Rogaine and Keeps Treatments?

As frequent causes of hair thinning and loss, DHT levels and poor circulation are proven to respond to medical treatment. But individual results still vary:

Keeps

In clinical trials, over 80% of men saw renewed hair growth using finasteride. Continued use is required to maintain benefits. Further studies confirm efficacy of combined oral plus topical approaches.

Tracking thousands of customers since 2018, Keeps reports excellent effectiveness for most men following the treatment plan as directed. Under a doctor‘s supervision, solutions can be adjusted for better results.

But response levels depend greatly on personal factors like age, genetics, and lifestyle habits.

Rogaine

Across multiple clinical studies of Rogaine products, the following was demonstrated:

  • Up to 50% increase in hair regrowth with 5% men’s minoxidil
  • Up to 25% more hair re-growth with 5% solution vs. 2% formulation
  • Continued use showed progressive improvements

However, individual results still vary even among study participants. About 20% of men report little to no new growth. For others, shedding may occur before seeing improvement.

The Verdict?

Based on clinical evidence and customer reviews, both Rogaine and Keeps can effectively treat hair loss—but consistency is key.

It may take 3 or more months before seeing noticeable results. Plus some individuals respond better than others depending on health, genetics and adherence to treatment. In fact, users following directions carefully had the best outcomes.

Keeps may have greater success by combining oral meds with Rogaine‘s topical minoxidil. But for some, sticking to one proven treatment keeps things simple.

Keeps vs Rogaine: Cost Comparison

Next let‘s break down the pricing and value you can expect:

Keeps Pricing

Keeps hair loss subscriptions include:

  • Initial online diagnosis & treatment plan
  • Prescription medications
  • 24/7 messaging with Keeps doctors
  • Progress tracking
  • Ongoing prescription refills

Here‘s what members pay:

  • Finasteride only – $28-$33 per month
  • Minoxidil only – $12-$35 per month
  • Fin & min combo – $40-$83 per month

You save 5-15% by prepaying for 6 or 12 months upfront. Additional hair supplements and products would incur extra costs.

Rogaine Pricing

As an over-the-counter treatment, Rogaine simply charges for the topical formula itself. Prices run from $30 to $100+ depending on type, strength, quantity, etc.

Here are a few examples:

  • Men’s 5% liquid – $52 for 3-month supply
  • Women’s 5% foam – $54 for 3 cans
  • Men’s unscented foam – $103 for 6 cans

Subscribe-and-save drops these prices by 20%. The company also offers multi-packs (like buy 3, get 1 free) and rebates throughout the year.

Value Comparison

Rogaine is the more affordable solution for purchase price alone. However, Keeps provides medications plus licensed medical oversight in an ongoing subscription. This comprehensive approach is valuable depending on your needs and preferences.

Consider Rogaine if:

  • You want an inexpensive, over-the-counter solution
  • You don‘t require finasteride or nutraceuticals
  • You only experience minor hair shedding or thinning

Keeps has greater value if:

  • Your loss is significant or genetic
  • You want finasteride, supplements or other treatments
  • Access to doctors and progress tracking matter

For many shoppers, the complete package of medication, medical expertise, and monitoring makes Keeps‘ higher price tag worthwhile.

Convenience: Rogaine vs. Keeps

From purchasing to application, day-to-day use is key for both products. Let‘s see how user-friendly Keeps and Rogaine are designed:

Keeps Convenience Factors

  • Delivered to your door every 90 days
  • Pills and topicals simple to take/apply daily
  • Online progress tracking and consultations
  • Can message doctors or chat via telehealth app
  • Lower maintenance than office visits every 90 days

After the initial questionnaire, Keeps streamlines hair loss treatment with scheduled refills, virtual check-ins, and more. Monitoring progress online is also convenient.

How Easy Is Rogaine?

  • Available online and in major retailers
  • Apply foam or liquid twice daily
  • Sets into scalp within minutes after applying
  • Store at room temperature away from heat
  • Can request before/after photos from other users

As an established hair growth brand, Rogaine offers accessibility online or in-store without requiring a prescription. But keeping up with daily application is key to maintain results. And without subscriptions or reminders, consistency with treatment can be tricky.

Ease of Use Verdict

For most guys, both Rogaine foam/liquid and Keeps oral meds are simple enough to apply/take daily. But if you’re prone to forgetting medical treatment, Keeps’ scheduled refills and doctor check-ins promote consistency.

Rogaine wins for grab-and-go convenience from common retailers. Yet for peace of mind, Keeps’ guided approach ensures you track progress and stay on schedule.

Potential Side Effects

Before choosing any hair loss treatment, it‘s smart to educate yourself on potential adverse reactions:

Keeps Side Effects

As an oral medication, finasteride poses a risk of systemic side effects including:

  • Decreased libido
  • Erectile dysfunction
  • Depression and anxiety

However clinical studies showed these only occurred in ~2% of men, were mild, and reversed upon stopping meds.

Minoxidil can sometimes cause skin irritation, dryness or flaking around the treatment area. Adjusting application amount or frequency often resolves this.

Rogaine Side Effects

Applied topically, Rogaine side effects tend to be localized around the scalp and hairline. These may include:

  • Itchiness and flaking skin
  • Headaches
  • Unwanted hair growth on face and hands

Side effects typically stay mild and either subside with continued use or discontinuation.

But some individuals may react poorly to propylene glycol in Rogaine, which allows minoxidil to penetrate the skin. Trying an alternative formula without this additive could help sensitive users.

The Takeaway

For most patients, side effects from Rogaine and Keeps prove minor and reversible when they occur. But it‘s smart to know the risks before starting treatment.

Check with your doctor about any medications or pre-existing conditions, as these impact suitability. Reading directions carefully and tracking your body‘s response at first helps minimize adverse reactions.

What Do Customer Reviews Say?

Based on user ratings across various sites, both options earn an average 4 out of 5 stars. Here is what real customers love about each:

Keeps Reviews

Verified buyers compliment Keeps for:

  • Convenience and ease of monthly delivery model
  • Seeing stalled hair loss turn around in 4-6 months
  • Improved hairline, thickness and confidence
  • Affordable pricing with ability to customize treatment

Negative feedback cites inconsistent refill shipment times, ineffective results for some, and difficulty reaching customer service.

Rogaine Reviews

Happy Rogaine users report:

  • Significant hair regrowth and reduction in shedding
  • Good value for an over-the-counter solution
  • No major side effects when following directions
  • Pleased with thickness achieved from continued use

Downsides mentioned involve skin flaking in early stages, frustration when skipping applications, and hit/miss results for a minority.

What Customers Say…

Based on user ratings across various sites, both options earn an average 4 out of 5 stars. Reviewers widely agree Rogaine and Keeps can effectively treat hair loss when applied/taken properly and consistently over months.

The Final Verdict: Keeps vs Rogaine

While Rogaine and Keeps take different approaches to hair regrowth, both provide proven solutions to common baldness and thinning. Choosing the right one for your situation boils down to:

  • Your specific hair loss cause and needs – Genetic? Temporary shedding? Receding hairline?
  • Your budget – Can you afford an extra $20-$60 per month?
  • How involved you want to be – Just apply daily foam or take meds + track progress?
  • Any pre-existing health factors – Finasteride restrictions?

Evaluate the above considerations against the key strengths of each brand:

Rogaine Keeps
Cost $$ $$$
Convenience Over-counter and accessible Auto-refills and doctor access
Approach Topical minoxidil Oral and topical customized
Performance Positive if used consistently Positive if treatment fits needs

Weigh your priorities against the two brands’ strengths above. Severe loss and want medical guidance? Keeps. Just want an affordable topical? Go Rogaine.

Still unsure where to start treating hair loss? Consult a doctor, as they can best assess your situation and needs before recommending Rogaine, Keeps or alternative treatments.

How useful was this post?

Click on a star to rate it!

Average rating 0 / 5. Vote count: 0

No votes so far! Be the first to rate this post.