As a dance lover and concerned parent, I do not recommend Dance Moms as quality viewing content for kids under 12. While the show highlights talented young dancers, it thrives on drama between aggressive moms and teachers that promotes unhealthy messages for children. Dance Moms features provocative choreography, screaming matches, and harmful teaching methods that have no place in a child‘s dance experience.
After analyzing the show’s content and impact from my perspective as a dance enthusiast, I strongly believe Dance Moms crosses the line for immature audiences. There are more positive, uplifting dance shows, movies and activities for kids to enjoy without the damaging themes pervasive in Dance Moms.
Why Dance Moms Concerns Child Development Experts
Dance Moms gives viewers unprecedented access into the fast-paced competition dance circuit. The show centers around Abby Lee Miller’s famous Abby Lee Dance Company (ALDC) studio. Miller notoriously pushes her hand-picked competition team to perfection under intense training schedules.
The show also heavily features the young dancers’ mothers, portrayed as aggressively invested in their daughters‘ success. Frequent blow up fights between Miller, the moms, and dancers create much of the show’s drama.
While entertaining, many parents and psychologists warn Dance Moms promotes inappropriate themes and an unhealthy environment for kids involved:
-
Abusive teaching methods: Miller regularly insults students’ appearances, talent, and reduces them to tears. Her harsh approach resembles psychological abuse according to child psychologists.
-
Development of anxiety/depression: The non-stop competition framed as all-consuming places incredible stress on young dancers that clinical studies link to serious mental health risks.
-
Promotion of disordered eating: Dancers face immense pressure to stay thin for skimpy costumes, fostering body image issues and eating disorders.
-
Normalization of aggression: Physical and verbal altercations between moms models immature conduct and aggression as acceptable.
-
Sexualization of minors: Suggestive choreography, lyrics and costumes sexualize underage dancers which the American Psychological Association (APA) warns can lead to sexual abuse and objectification.
But does the disturbing environment shown on Dance Moms accurately represent the real world of children’s dance?
Reality TV Exaggerations Versus Real-Life Dance
There is no doubt the drama of Dance Moms gets artificially amped up by producers to make compelling TV. The intense conflicts, teaching methods, and competitive pressure portrayed likely exceed typical real-world dance studios.
However, Dance Moms still presents a concerning model for young viewers even if not completely realistic. And make no mistake – the mature themes and inappropriate content on the show reflect real issues facing child dancers today.
Let‘s explore the facts around risks glamorized on Dance Moms that threaten real children’s health and safety:
-
Overtraining prevalence: 45% of competitive dancers (age 10-14) train more than 16 hours per week, risking physical injury, stunted growth and erosion of normal childhood activities.
-
Widespread body image issues: 45-97% of female dancers struggle with an eating disorder. Girls as young as 5 report dieting to achieve the stereotypical dancer “look”.
-
Verbal abuse reports: 53% of elite child dancers (average age 11) reported experiencing occasional/frequent verbal/physical abuse from coaches.
-
Sexual exploitation: Dancers under 18 comprise over 40% of identified trafficking victims with experts attributing this to the sexualized normalization of girls in dance.
This data makes clear that while embellished for TV, Dance Moms illuminates systemic issues facing real child dancers – many of them minors – across the United States.
Adult Themes In Dance Moms Are Inappropriate For Young Kids
Child media experts argue that much of the content on Dance Moms is developmentally inappropriate or harmful for kids under 12 years old given their still-developing maturity and critical thinking skills.
Alarming Evidence of Sexualization
A primary complaint is sexualized costuming, provocative dance moves, and inappropriate song lyrics for the tween and teen cast.
-
Suggestive costumes like exposing bras, panties, midriffs and dressing as sexualized characters.
-
Routines and music with provocative themes including suicide, racism, domestic abuse.
-
Dancers emulating adult interactions via romantic/violent choreography ill-suited for their age and psychological immaturity.
According to the APA Task Force, this prominent sexualization shown exploiting minors on Dance Moms constitutes a form of sexual abuse given research showing negative impacts on mental health, self-esteem and normal development.
Normalization of Aggression and Bullying
Regular screaming matches between the moms and Abby Lee Miller demonstrate damaging conflict resolution methods to young viewers. Their aggression escalates into threats, gossiping, physical restraint and even slapping other adults on camera.
Studies confirm children exposed to domestic violence experience anxiety, depression, poor anger management and increased school troubles. The explosive adult conflict in Dance Moms teaches immature audiences to view aggression as a normal or effective outlet for anger and frustration.
Miller‘s harsh teaching approach also normalizes a disturbing level of verbal and mental abuse. Belittling students until they cry, mocking their looks, pitting them against each other are not acceptable coaching practices for any age. This disturbing behavioral modeling has concerning influences on children‘s developing social skills and own conflict resolution tactics.
Mature Viewer Development Needed
Based on cognitive development research, the concerning content pervasive in Dance Moms matches the maturity level of viewers 12 and older who better understand reality TV exaggeration, appropriately process complex social conflicts, and separate their identity/self-worth from media portrayals.
Younger children under 10 lack these critical analysis skills and high levels of emotional intelligence. They remain highly impressionable to the inappropriate behaviors and themes modeled in Dance Moms which research proves can manifest in social, physical and mental health issues.
Healthy Dance Alternatives For Kids To Enjoy
As a parent, you can foster love of dance in children without exposing them to the damaging themes prevalent in Dance Moms. Focus on fun, cooperative environments versus extreme competition.
Great Options Include:
- Community theater dance teams
- Recreational dance studios (3-5 hours/week)
- School dance programs
- Church/non-profit dance groups
- Dance-themed movies like Center Stage (2000, PG-13), High Strung (2016, PG)
These settings allow kids to safely learn choreography, gain confidence in dance skills, and participate in low-pressure recitals/performances. Seek out class environments focused on teamwork over cutthroat competition and positive communication over physical appearance/rankings.
Age-Appropriate Dance Limits:
- Ages 3-9: 3-4 hours/week
- Ages 10-12: 5-8 hours/week
- Ages 13-15: 10-15 hours/week
- Ages 16+: 15-20 hours/week
With reasonable limits and positive environments, children can tap into their passion for dance as a source of joy, creativity, and exercise. Reserve highly competitive dance contexts like those portrayed on Dance Moms for mature dancers ages 15 and up.
The Bottom Line – Keep Dance Moms Away From Young Kids!
While Dance Moms gives us a glimpse into the dedication competitive dance demands, its conflicts, sexualized content and high-pressure environment clearly cross ethical lines for child participants and viewers.
I strongly recommend no child under 12 directly watch the show without guidance given inappropriate themes like sexualization of minors, bullying, and verbal abuse. Children 8 and under lack the maturity to properly digest or resist such harmful messaging and behavioral modeling.
Instead expose kids to dance through age-appropriate alternatives focused on cooperation and technique growth over rankings and cutthroat competition. With the right guidance, kids can cultivate a lifelong passion for dance without suffering damaging effects like those witnessed on Dance Moms.
There are plenty of positive dance shows, activities and competitive contexts to explore as kids mature. As parents, we must keep age-inappropriate content like Dance Moms far away from impressionable young children to protect their health and safety as they blossom into skillful, confident dancers.
