How Much Does It Cost To Get Coins Graded: An In-Depth Guide

Whether you‘re a seasoned numismatist or a novice collector, one question that inevitably arises is: how much does it cost to get coins professionally graded? Grading is a crucial aspect of coin collecting that can significantly impact a coin‘s value and liquidity in the marketplace. In this comprehensive guide, we‘ll dive deep into the world of coin grading, exploring its history, the grading process, and most importantly, the costs associated with getting your coins evaluated by experts.

What is Coin Grading and Why Does It Matter?

Coin grading is the process of determining a coin‘s condition and authenticity by a trusted third-party grading service. Numismatic experts meticulously examine each coin, assessing factors such as wear, luster, strike, and overall eye appeal. The coin is then assigned a grade on a 70-point scale, known as the Sheldon Scale, ranging from Poor (P-1) to Perfect Uncirculated (MS-70).

Grading matters because a coin‘s condition directly correlates with its value. Even a slight difference in grade can mean a substantial difference in price. Moreover, a graded coin comes sealed in a tamper-evident holder with a certification label, providing assurance of authenticity and protection from further wear. This third-party validation instills confidence in buyers and often enhances a coin‘s marketability.

A Brief History of Coin Grading

Coin grading standards have evolved over time. In the early days of collecting, grades were subjectively assigned by dealers and collectors using terms like "Good," "Fine," or "Uncirculated." However, inconsistencies in grading led to the need for a more standardized system.

In 1948, well-known numismatist Dr. William Sheldon developed the Sheldon Scale, a 70-point grading system that is still used today. But it wasn‘t until the 1980s that third-party grading really took off with the establishment of the Professional Coin Grading Service (PCGS) and the Numismatic Guaranty Corporation (NGC). These respected companies pioneered the concept of impartial, reliable coin grading and encapsulation.

The Coin Grading Process

Getting a coin graded involves several steps:

  1. Submission – The collector fills out a form detailing the coin‘s information and ships it to the grading company.

  2. Receiving – Upon receipt, coins are entered into the company‘s tracking system.

  3. Grading – Coins are carefully examined by multiple graders who determine the grade.

  4. Encapsulation – After grading, coins are sonically sealed in a protective plastic holder with a label displaying the grade, description, and a unique certification number.

  5. Return – Graded coins are shipped back to the owner.

The entire process can take anywhere from weeks to months, depending on the service level selected.

Grading Criteria and the Sheldon Scale

Graders look at several key factors when evaluating a coin:

  • Strike – The sharpness and completeness of the coin‘s design details.
  • Preservation – The amount of wear or damage the coin has sustained.
  • Luster – The quality and quantity of a coin‘s original mint shine.
  • Eye Appeal – The coin‘s overall visual attractiveness.

Each coin is assigned a numeric grade from 1 to 70 based on these criteria. Grades of 60 or higher indicate an uncirculated coin, while coins graded lower exhibit varying degrees of wear. The higher the grade, the more valuable the coin.

Factors Affecting Coin Grading Costs

Several variables impact the cost of getting a coin graded:

  1. Grading Service Membership Fees

To submit coins, you generally need to be a member of the grading service. For example:

  • PCGS offers memberships ranging from $69 (Silver) to $249 (Platinum) per year, with higher tiers including free grading vouchers.

  • NGC memberships range from free (limited access) to $299 (Elite) annually, with perks like grading credits and bulk submission rates at higher levels.

  1. Grading Tier Fees

Grading companies charge per-coin fees based on factors like coin type (modern vs. vintage), declared value, and service level (turnaround time). For instance:

  • PCGS modern coin grading starts at $20-30 for regular members while vintage can range from $35-100+.

  • NGC charges $18-25 for modern and $30-75 for vintage coins for their lowest tiers.

  1. Add-On Services

Optional services like professional imaging, variety attribution, or conservation can add to the overall cost. These extras can range from a few dollars to hundreds depending on the service.

  1. Shipping and Insurance

You‘ll need to factor in secure shipping costs both ways. Fees depend on the carrier, speed, and declared value which determines insurance. Expect anywhere from $30-$100+ for a submission.

Putting It All Together: The Range of Grading Costs

Considering all the variables, the total cost of getting a coin graded can span a wide range. Here are some example scenarios:

  • Modern bullion coin, regular service: $20-30 membership + $20 grading + $30 shipping = $70-80 total

  • Mid-value vintage coin, faster service: $150 membership + $50 grading + $20 imaging + $60 shipping = $280 total

  • High-value rarity, top tier service with extras: $300 membership + $500 grading + $100 imaging + $150 shipping = $1,050+ total

As you can see, grading costs can add up quickly, especially for more valuable coins and premium services. Careful consideration is key to ensure grading is worth the expense.

To Grade or Not to Grade?

Given the costs, when does it make sense to get a coin graded? A good rule of thumb is that grading is worthwhile when the coin is scarce and high grade examples carry a significant premium over raw coins. Generally, coins expected to grade 65 or higher are good candidates as this level of preservation is considered gem quality.

On the flip side, for common coins or those in lower conditions, grading fees can quickly exceed any bump in value provided by the holder. In these cases, it‘s often more economical to sell the coin raw.

It‘s also wise to consider grading if you plan to sell a coin valued over $1000. The assurance of authenticity and grade will attract more buyers willing to pay top dollar.

The Perks of Buying Graded

While getting coins graded yourself can be costly, buying coins already graded offers several advantages:

  • Confidence in authenticity and condition as determined by experts
  • No surprises – you know exactly what you‘re getting
  • Protection from wear and environmental damage in the holder
  • Easier to value and sell with widespread pricing guides for graded coins

Of course, you‘ll pay more upfront for a graded coin versus a raw one. But for expensive key dates and top condition rarities, the benefits can be well worth the premium.

Making the Grade: Is Your Coin Worth It?

If you‘re on the fence about grading a coin, consider these questions:

  1. Is the coin scarce or rare?
  2. Is it in exceptional condition for the issue?
  3. Will grading fees be a small percentage of the coin‘s value?
  4. Do you plan to sell in the near future?
  5. Would a grade significantly increase marketability?

If you answered yes to most of these, grading may be a smart move. When in doubt, it‘s always best to consult with a trusted dealer or numismatic expert for guidance based on your specific coin.

The Bottom Line on Coin Grading Costs

As we‘ve explored, the cost of getting coins graded depends on a multitude of factors from grading service and membership level to coin value and add-on options. While there‘s no one-size-fits-all answer, careful consideration of the coin‘s rarity, condition, and potential premium will help you make an informed decision.

In the end, grading is an investment in protecting and often enhancing a coin‘s value in the marketplace. But like any investment, it‘s important to weigh the upfront costs against the expected returns. Armed with knowledge and expert advice when needed, you‘ll be well equipped to make savvy choices in your collecting journey.

How useful was this post?

Click on a star to rate it!

Average rating 0 / 5. Vote count: 0

No votes so far! Be the first to rate this post.