My Honest Get Maine Lobster Review (2500+ Words)

As a seafood lover living far from the coast, I rely on delivery services like Get Maine Lobster to enjoy fresh lobster from the docks of Maine. After over a year as a happy subscriber, I want to share an in-depth review of my experiences. Keep reading to see if Get Maine Lobster is worth it for fellow foodies!

Overview of Get Maine Lobster

Founded in 2009, Get Maine Lobster pioneered premium seafood delivery across America. Their sustainable lobster and shellfish arrive next-day from fishing towns in Maine. As a customer since 2021, I’ve ordered all kinds of products from live lobsters to pre-made dinner kits.

So what makes Get Maine Lobster stand out?

First, their focus on supporting local lobstermen using responsible harvesting is key. Overfishing by large commercial operators damages ecosystems, but Get Maine Lobster’s suppliers follow generations-old practices. This promotes future growth of the industry.

And because lobster populations remain healthy, we customers get to eat sweeter, better-tasting meat. After years buying from local supermarkets, I immediately noticed the difference Get Maine Lobster’s sustainably caught seafood makes through delicate texture and briny sweetness.

Unboxing My First Get Maine Lobster Order

Growing up in Kansas, enjoying fresh lobster was basically impossible twenty years ago. So when I first discovered Get Maine Lobster delivered premium seafood overnight across America, I felt giddy as a kid on Christmas morning.

For my first order, I decided to get the Full Lobster Dinner for Two to enjoy with my husband.

The meal kit included:

• 2 live 1.25-1.5 pound lobsters
• Premium rolls for lobster rolls
• 1 lb lobster meat
• Corn on the cob
• Blueberry pie

It felt crazy having a box of live lobsters shipped to my doorstep in Missouri! But the Get Maine Lobster packaging was neatly designed with insulation and gel packs to keep everything cool. Each claw was banded to prevent escapees.

I was blown away cracking into the gorgeously colored lobster shells later that night. The tails contained beautifully crisp meat dripping with buttery juices. The website’s cooking tips helped us nail that perfect slightly charred texture.

We had WAY too much fun whipping up overflowing lobster rolls and digging into the blueberry pie after. For less than a nice steakhouse dinner out, this kit provided an incredible at-home date night!

Get Maine Lobster vs Lobster Online Competition

In compiling this Get Maine Lobster Review guide, I couldn‘t help but compare them to competitors like Lobster Anywhere, Harbor Fish Market and Lobster Gram. I was curious how other leading lobster delivery brands stacked up.

After comparing core factors like product selection, pricing, and online reviews, Get Maine Lobster outshines the rest for overall value.

Brand	Product Range	Price Per Lobster	Reviews
Get Maine Lobster	125+ options	$13-$20 each	4.7/5 from 2,300+ buyers
Lobster Anywhere	65 choices	$15-$25 each	3.2/5 from 850+ customers
Harbor Fish Market	89 options	$17-$27 each	4.3/5 from 1,700+ reviews
Lobster Gram	105 products	$14-$23 each	4.4/5 from 1,250+ ratings

I especially love Get Maine Lobster‘s selection including lobster bake kits, dinner bundles for two, and monthly subscription boxes. Their Harvesters Program supporting local fishermen also beats corporate competitors.

Supporting Lobster Sustainability with Get Maine Lobster

Did you know the American lobster population decreased by 70% from the late ‘90s up through the early 2010s?

Overfishing and environmental changes nearly decimated stocks, but recent conservation efforts helped rates rebound significantly. Still, balancing commercial demand with sustainable practices remains an ongoing challenge.

That’s why responsible providers like Get Maine Lobster matter. Their network of Maine fishermen catch lobster using centuries-old techniques passed through generations:

• Hand-made traps allow small juveniles and egg-carrying mothers to escape unharmed
• Restricting catch quantities during molting seasons limits disruption
• V-notching female tails for identification protects reproduction

These practices allow fishers to profit enough to support families while preserving the environment’s balance. Get Maine Lobster also packages orders in recyclable materials made mostly using renewable resources.

So by choosing Get Maine Lobster over some anonymous national food distributor, your purchase helps caretakers, not corporations. Plus it rewards you back with better quality. What a perfect example of voting for change with our dollars!

Putting Get Maine Lobster Products to the Test in My Kitchen

Beyond sustainability and harvest practices, Get Maine Lobster‘s true test comes down to taste. Their product catalog spans everything from live lobsters to value meal kits so families anywhere can enjoy quintessential New England seafood.

After a year enjoying Get Maine Lobster subscription boxes, here are some of my favorite products I recommend:

Lobster Meat

The pre-picked lobster meat eliminates all effort to enjoy this sweet delicacy from antenna to tail. I love adding chunks to my seafood pasta bakes or creamy risotto. Treat yourself to a lobster BLT sandwich piled sky-high too!

Petite Lobster Tails

Perfect single-serve size, I bake my petite tails with pumpkin spice compound butter. The richness pairs perfectly with the salty shellfish flavors. Drizzle your favorite vinaigrette over a lobster Cobb salad too.

Lobster & Seafood Dinner Kits

When I really want to pull out all the stops, the all-inclusive Seafood Dinner for 1 is ideal for preparing the ultimate feast at home.

The kit feeds 1 generously with:

• 5 oz. lobster tails
• Jumbo shrimp
• Tasty crab cakes
• Clam chowder
• Key lime pie

I also serve up their Cajun Surf & Turf Kit when hosting game nights with friends. Those lobster tails disappear fast every time!

Lobster Mac & Cheese

Honestly, Get Maine Lobster‘s epic seafood pasta casserole is worth ordering even without the subscription discount. Everything comes pre-prepped so all you need to do is mix, bake, and top with those crunchy seasoned panko breadcrumbs.

Lobster Roll Packs (Frozen)

I always keep a couple frozen Lobster Roll packs stocked as my emergency gourmet meal stash. Thaw the rolls, heat up some butter, add the generous lobster meat filling, and voila! Tastier and more affordable than restaurant alternatives.

No matter what you order from Get Maine Lobster, you simply can‘t find better quality and freshness without living on the Atlantic coast.

Get Maine Lobster Subscription Perks & Savings

The best way to enjoy Get Maine Lobster again and again is by joining a subscription program. I signed up at first hesitantly just to try it, but became a lifer once I saw the perks.

Subscription options range from three months to an entire year. You pay everything upfront, then Get Maine Lobster sends a monthly delivery on the date you choose.

Each shipment contains an awesome seafood mix including 2-5 lb. of lobster tails, premium cuts like tomahawk ribeyes or halibut, free gifts and so much more.

My favorite parts about subscribing are:

• Saving 15% off future orders
• Reward points to use for free gifts
• Exclusive member discounts and bonus extra goods
• First dibs on limited-edition products when available
• Confirming my delivery schedule months ahead of time

The surprise element keeps things exciting even for veterans like me. Unboxing each monthly package feels a bit like my birthday!

And you can always log into your Get Maine Lobster account to update delivery addresses or billing details. I temporarily paused my subscription for one month when I went on vacation out of state. Their flexible terms make it worthwhile.

Stellar Get Maine Lobster Customer Service

Companies can only achieve customer satisfaction scores as high as Get Maine Lobster’s thanks to providing exceptional support.

My interactions with their service team over the years always left me impressed by how much personal care goes into each order.

For example, one month USPS held my package in transit a bit too long due to winter weather delays. By the time it reached me 30 hours after shipping, some ice packs melted so a couple lobster tails didn’t look as fresh.

I snapped some photos and emailed Get Maine Lobster politely asking if I should be concerned about eating the intact-looking tails.

Kristina in customer service called me BACK personally to apologize and make sure I stayed happy. We had a wonderful 15-minute chat about good preparation tips too. In the end, Get Maine Lobster refunded the entire box and let me keep the extra food to boot!

Moments like those remind me Get Maine Lobster isn’t some faceless corporation. They treat subscribers like family. You bet I’ll repay that good faith by sharing this very detailed review!

Final Verdict: Get Maine Lobster 100% Earns My Recommendation

I hope this in-depth Get Maine Lobster review helps you decide if their service can satisfy your inner seafood fanatic too. After almost 18 months enjoying dozens of orders, I confidently vouch for their quality.

Here’s a quick final summary of my thoughts:

Pros

• Responsibly wild-caught, sustainable seafood
• Overnight shipping maintains unmatched freshness
• Huge variety of products, kits and recipes
• Generous portion sizes on meal packs
• Loyalty rewards for subscribers save money
• Phenomenal customer service guarantees happiness

Cons

• Premium quality demands higher prices
• Rare minor shipping mishaps with perishables
• Restricted delivery regions (48 states only)

As a longtime satisfied customer, I happily recommend Get Maine Lobster to anyone able to splurge on high-end seafood. The unforgettable flavors made possible by their small-scale local sourcing makes every purchase worthwhile. Just brace yourself for some seriously delicious dishes!

Thanks for reading and bon appétit from me to your dinner table!