Discovering the Most Valuable Antique Wood Planes

Have you ever held a piece of woodworking history in your hands? For passionate collectors and woodworkers, antique wood planes are cherished relics that represent the pinnacle of craftsmanship and ingenuity from a bygone era. These vintage tools were the secret behind the impossibly smooth surfaces and intricate moldings of 18th and 19th century furniture masterpieces.

Today, the rarest antique wood planes are prized possessions that can fetch jaw-dropping prices at auction – with the most sought-after models selling for $10,000 or more to discerning collectors! Whether you‘re an avid antique tool collector, a woodworking enthusiast, or simply appreciate fine craftsmanship, join me on a journey to uncover the most valuable antique wood planes and the fascinating stories behind them.

The Golden Age of Wood Planes

To truly appreciate antique wood planes, it‘s important to understand their rich history and the crucial role they played in woodworking and carpentry. The use of hand planes dates back thousands of years, but it was during the 18th and 19th centuries that wood plane making reached its zenith, with master craftsmen refining the tool to perfection.

During this golden age, over 100 distinct types of wood planes were developed, each designed for a specialized purpose – from large jointer planes for flattening boards to delicate compass planes for shaping curved surfaces. Planes ranged in size from tiny finger planes to massive panel-flattening behemoths over 2 feet long. Each one was a work of art, with elegant shapes, gleaming wood, and precision-fitted metal parts.

The mid-1800s saw an explosion of innovation in the wood plane industry, with the introduction of features like interchangeable cutters, mechanical blade adjustment, and toted handles for improved ergonomics. Bold inventors and manufacturers raced to patent new designs to gain an edge. By the end of the 19th century, wood planes had evolved into high-precision instruments capable of extraordinarily fine work.

However, the turn of the 20th century brought a gradual decline in the dominance of wood planes, as metallic planes and power tools gained popularity. While some traditionalist woodworkers continued to prefer wooden planes, many manufacturers scaled back production or went out of business entirely. This makes planes from the peak of the wooden plane era extremely rare and collectible today.

Profiles of the Most Valuable Antique Wood Planes

So which antique wood planes are the most sought-after by collectors and fetch the highest prices? Here are profiles of some of the most valuable wood planes and their makers:

Norris

Planes made by Thomas Norris of London are widely considered the gold standard of antique English wood planes. Prized for their elegant design and exotic wood veneers, original Norris planes can easily sell for over $5000, with rare models approaching the $10,000 mark.

The A1 panel plane, A5 jack plane, and A7 shoulder plane are among the most coveted Norris designs. However, be aware that many Norris planes were destroyed in a World War II bombing, and the company never fully recovered afterwards, making originals especially hard to come by.

Spiers

The Spiers company of Scotland was another titan of wood plane innovation, famed for introducing dovetailed steel planes in the 1840s. Spiers planes were known for their unmatched precision and distinctive shapes, with the iconic coffin-shaped smoothing plane being much imitated.

A matched set of mint condition Spiers planes is the ultimate prize for a tool collector, with individual specialty planes routinely breaking the $1000 barrier. The Spiers improved miter plane and dovetailed panel plane are particularly valuable.

American Masters

On the American side of the pond, a handful of craftsmen gained reputations for making planes that were functionally and aesthetically superior. Among the most revered are Cesar Chelor and Hazard Knowles, Connecticut plane makers active in the early 19th century.
Planes stamped with their maker‘s mark are exceedingly rare, with only a few dozen verified examples known to exist. On the very rare occasions they come up for auction, these American masterpieces have sold for $5,000-10,000.

18th Century Wood Planes

Going back even further in time, planes from the 1700s have taken on an almost mythical status due to their incredible rarity. Only a precious few examples from makers like Francis Nicholson or Dutch-English planemaker Christiaan van Swieten have survived. These earliest known signed planes represent the very foundation of the craft.

Recently, a previously unknown American-made 18th century plane turned up on eBay and sold for nearly $6000 after a spirited bidding war. For collectors, finding a genuine pre-1800 plane is akin to spotting a unicorn in the wild.

What Makes an Antique Wood Plane Valuable?

Now that we‘ve met some of the most valuable wood planes in the world, let‘s examine the key factors that influence their value and collectibility:

Rarity

As with any antique, rarity is a primary driver of value. Planes made by small-scale or regional makers in limited quantities are inherently more sought-after than those mass-produced by large manufacturers. Planes that only exist in very small numbers due to age, historical events, or intentional scarcity (such as limited edition presentation pieces) command the highest prices.

Craftsmanship

The level of skill and artistry embodied in an antique wood plane directly impacts its value. Collectors prize planes that showcase the pinnacle of the planemaker‘s art – from flawless dovetailing to detailed engravings to perfectly flush-fitting exotic wood inlays. The amount of handwork and the complexity of the design separate the masterworks from the merely utilitarian.

Provenance

As with fine art, a plane‘s ownership history and maker can have a major impact on its value. Planes that can be traced back to noted makers or those with an interesting story behind them are more valuable than comparable examples of unknown origin. At the very top end, planes previously owned by luminaries like President John F. Kennedy have fetched over $20,000 at auction.

Condition

Of course, condition is key for any antique. Planes that have survived the centuries unscathed by wear, corrosion, or damage are extremely rare and prized by collectors. Planes in mint or near mint condition will always attract the most interest and the highest bids. However, even incomplete or imperfect planes from certain makers are still quite valuable due to their rarity.

Identifying and Valuing an Antique Wood Plane

If you think you may have a valuable antique wood plane on your hands, here are some tips to help identify and evaluate it:

  1. Examine the plane closely for any maker‘s marks, stamps, or labels. Most high-end plane makers signed their work, often on the toe or heel of the plane. Consult guidebooks or online resources to decipher any marks you find.

  2. Look for signs of age and hand craftsmanship such as dovetailed bodies, artistic chamfering, hand-cut threads on adjusting screws, and hand-forged hardware. Generally, the older the plane and the more handwork, the more valuable it is likely to be.

  3. Try to identify the specific type and purpose of the plane based on its size, shape, and configuration. Specialty planes tend to be rarer and more valuable than basic bench planes. Consult a reference like Alvin Sellens‘ "The Stanley Plane" or Clarence Blanchard‘s "Wooden Plane Makers of the United States".

  4. Evaluate the plane‘s overall condition. Is it complete or missing parts? Are there any cracks, chips, or major wear? The more pristine the plane, the more it will be worth.

  5. If you suspect you have a very old or valuable plane, consider having it authenticated by a recognized expert. A SAPFM (Society of American Period Furniture Makers) tool appraiser or antique tools dealer can provide an informed opinion and valuation.

Preserving and Caring for Collectible Wood Planes

To maintain the value of your antique wood plane collection, it‘s important to care for your planes properly. Keep them clean, dry, and out of direct sunlight or extreme temperatures to prevent cracking, checking, and corrosion. Store them in a climate-controlled environment if possible.

If you wish to use an antique plane as a working tool, do so carefully. Don‘t use antique planes on metal, plastics, or painted surfaces which can damage the sole. Be gentle when adjusting the blade to avoid stressing old threads. Regularly wipe down the metal parts with camellia oil to prevent rust.

Consider keeping your most valuable planes on display rather than subjecting them to wear. You can also have a custom protective box made to store a prized plane. If a plane is in need of restoration, leave major repairs to a professional experienced in antique tools to avoid harming its value.

Where to See the World‘s Best Wood Plane Collections

Want to see more incredible antique wood planes in person? Visit one of these world-class collections:

  • The Smithsonian Institution in Washington DC has an extensive collection of 18th and 19th century American planes.

  • The Boulton Historic Site in Toronto houses the largest public collection of British wood planes in North America.

  • The Nieuwendijk European Woodworking Plane Museum in the Netherlands contains over 1500 antique continental wood planes.

Final Thoughts

I hope this in-depth look at the most valuable antique wood planes has given you a new appreciation for these marvels of human ingenuity and craftsmanship. Whether you‘re motivated to start your own collection or simply enjoy learning about antique tools, the world of wood planes is endlessly fascintating.

For woodworking purists, using an antique wood plane is a singular experience that connects you directly to generations of craftspeople. Feeling the heft of a 200-year-old plane in your hands and hearing the whisper of the blade as it slices a gossamer shaving is pure magic. In that moment, the centuries melt away.

Collector or user, we are united by a shared reverence for the planemakers of old, who elevated a humble carpenter‘s tool into a work of art. By preserving and cherishing these antique planes, we keep their legacy alive. So the next time you see a dusty old wooden plane at a flea market or garage sale, pick it up and give it a closer look – it just might be a piece of history in the making!

Frequently Asked Questions

Q: Are antique wood planes better than modern planes?
A: In terms of performance, high-quality modern planes can do everything an antique plane can, and often with more precision and less maintenance. However, many woodworkers prefer the feel and experience of using a well-tuned antique wood plane. It really comes down to personal preference.

Q: Do antique wood planes need to be restored to be used?
A: It depends on the condition of the individual plane. Some antique planes just need a good cleaning and honing to be workable. Others may have warped bodies, missing or broken parts, or damaged irons that require repair. In general, planes made before 1850 are best left in original condition to preserve their value.

Q: What is the most ever paid for an antique wood plane?
A: While auction records are not always public, the most expensive antique plane sale that can be verified is the $23,000 paid in 2004 for a plane used by President John F. Kennedy. However, there are rumors of private sales that may have exceeded this amount for ultra-rare 18th century planes.

Q: What kind of wood were antique wood planes made from?
A: Traditionally, beech and hornbeam were the most common woods used for plane bodies in Europe, while apple, maple, birch, and boxwood were favored by American makers. Plane makers also used a wide variety of decorative woods like ebony, rosewood, and mahogany for knobs and veneers.

Q: How can I learn more about collecting antique wood planes?
A: Join a tool collecting association like EAIA (Early American Industries Association) or MWTCA (Mid-West Tool Collectors Association) to connect with other collectors and access resources. Attend tool auctions and antique tool shows to handle planes in person and learn from experts. And of course, read widely on the subject – start with classics like "The Wooden Plane" by John M. Whelan.

How useful was this post?

Click on a star to rate it!

Average rating 0 / 5. Vote count: 0

No votes so far! Be the first to rate this post.